Enter ZIP Code

Cheap Auto Insurance U.S.Cheap Car Insurance New York → Bay Shore (Suffolk County)

Looking for cheap car insurance in Bay Shore (NY)? You have come to the right place!

On our website you will see quotes and rates offered by insurance companies, as well as be able to choose and send an application online.

We know how good it is to be safe in a car while driving but various situations may happen sometimes. That's why it's better to insure your car first after buying.

What do you need to do for this? Enter your ZIP code, choose an insurance company or agency, and send your request.

Soon you'll get a reply from the company representative. We wish you a safe driving and a good mood!

We offer car insurance in Bay Shore (Suffolk County), NY:



Car Insurance Agents in Bay Shore, NY

Acme Insurance of Bay Shore Inc

1716 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 1171 near Emily St,penataquit Ave

Call: (631) 665-6464
Get a Quote

Allstate Insurance

2115 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 1171  near Union Blvd,brentwood Rd

Call: (631) 505-3667
Get a Quote

Chase Bank

1650 5Th Ave, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 1171  near 5th Ave,new Hampshire Ave

Call: (631) 231-8770
Get a Quote

Jay Tee Insurance

1655 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 3422  near 5th Ave,drexel Dr

Call: (631) 231-3200
Get a Quote

Michael Nocella - Allstate Insurance Agent

50 Park Ave, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 7309 

Call: (631) 328-2280
Get a Quote

Monica Murphy - State Farm Insurance Agent

1750 5Th Ave, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 1171  near 5th Ave,candlewood Rd

Call: (631) 273-1800
Get a Quote

Norma Gorman Insurance Agency Inc

1401 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 5251  near Brentwood Rd,texas Ave

Call: (631) 666-6600
Get a Quote

STAGNITTA MICHAEL INSURANCE AGENT

90B W Main St, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 1171 

Call: (631) 666-8350
Get a Quote

Yvette Korell - Nationwide Insurance

1647 5Th Ave, Bay Shore, NY - 11706 - 1171  near 5th Ave,drexel Dr

Call: (631) 328-5500
Get a Quote


Bay Shore, NY Auto Insurance Rates

Bay Shore, NY residents can save $480 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Bay Shore car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

LowestAverageHighest
$750 $1,190 $6,410

Bay Shore Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Bay Shore, NY's average car insurance of $1190 differs from North Bay Shore (+$90), Islip, NY (-$170), North Babylon (-$100) and New York (+$179)

Bay Shore North Bay Shore Islip, NY North Babylon New York
Median Insurance Rates $1190 +$90 -$170 -$100 +$179

Bay Shore Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Bay Shore Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Bay Shore Bay Shore Driver Demographics Bay Shore Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Bay Shore Insurance Savings
Other Area
Boyd Ave1997 Toyota T100 SR537 year married woman$956$750
Kempster Ave2002 Acura MDX Touring w/Navi53 year married man$1,612$324
Catherine St2006 Chrysler Town and Country Touring21 year woman$1,012$792
Lakeside Ln2009 Volkswagen Tiguan S16 year male teenager$2,365$942
N 1st Ave2005 Nissan 350Z Grand Touring49 year man$1,538$556
Bay Wood
Montauk Dr2008 Honda Civic Si70 year female senior$1,116$421
Seminole Dr2012 Mazda MAZDA6 i Touring19 year female teenager$2,146$391
Baldwin Blvd2007 GMC Sierra 1500 SLT76 year male senior$1,342$322
Lombardy Blvd2014 Kia Optima LX65 year senior$1,220$331
Poplar Pl2013 Dodge Grand Caravan SE18 year teenager$2,335$687

Bay Shore Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Bay Shore North Bay Shore Central Islip North Great River New York
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $2213 +$167 +$353 -$446 +$333
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $4668 +$354 +$746 -$941 +$703
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $4337 +$327 +$692 -$874 +$653

The Post DUI insurance in Bay Shore, NY's is $2213 compared to North Bay Shore (+$167), Central Islip (+$353), North Great River (-$446) and New York (+$333)

In Bay Shore, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $331 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2006 Chrysler Town and Country Touring in Bay Shore, NY would pay $4272 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $3969.

Bay Shore Car Insurance by Segment

Bay Shore Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

2042 Bay Shore Teenagers (7% of total population), 56% Male & 44% Female.

Bay Shore West Babylon Brightwaters Brentwood New York
All Teenagers $2427 -$204 +$1306 +$245 +$365
Male Teenager $2510 -$211 +$1351 +$254 +$378
Female Teenager $2332 -$196 +$1254 +$235 +$351

Bay Shore teenagers pay $2427 in insurance in contrast with West Babylon (-$204), Brightwaters (+$1306), Brentwood (+$245) and New York (+$365). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Bay Shore is $178

Example

  • 2014 Hyundai Tucson SE Male Teenager Insurance Rate $2,418
  • 2013 Ford Fusion SE Female Teenager Insurance Rate $2,185

Bay Shore Men & Women Car Insurance

27887 Bay Shore Adults (100% of total population), 50% Men & 50% Women.

Bay Shore Great River West Bay Shore Deer Park New York
All Women $1106 +$614 +$614 -$149 +$167
Married Women $1071 +$594 +$594 -$144 +$161
All Men $1654 +$917 +$917 -$223 +$248
Married Men $1594 +$885 +$885 -$214 +$240

The typical insurance rate of $1654 that Bay Shore Men pay varies from Great River (+$917), West Bay Shore (+$917), Deer Park (-$223) and New York (+$248). In Bay Shore, married men pay $523 more than married women.

Example

  • 2011 Lincoln MKS Base Married Men Insurance Rate $2,099
  • 2013 Buick LaCrosse Leather Married Women Insurance Rate $1,455

Bay Shore Senior Car Insurance

4883 Bay Shore Seniors (17% of total population), 45% Senior Men & 55% Senior Women.

Bay Shore Brightwaters Brentwood Great River New York
All Seniors $1344 +$723 +$136 +$746 +$202
Senior Men $1428 +$768 +$144 +$792 +$214
Senior Women $1237 +$666 +$125 +$687 +$186

Bay Shore seniors pay $1344 in insurance compared to Brightwaters (+$723), Brentwood (+$136), Great River (+$746) and New York (+$202). In Bay Shore, senior men pay $191 more than senior women.

Bay Shore Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Bay Shore Population with 1 Vehicle 3083 (33% of Bay Shore population), 2 Vehicles 3043 (33% of the Bay Shore population) and 3 vehicles 1138 (12% of the population)

Bay Shore North Great River Brentwood Central Islip New York
2 Vehicles $2261 -$456 +$228 +$361 +$341
3 Vehicles $3451 -$696 +$348 +$551 +$520
4 Vehicles $4641 -$936 +$468 +$741 +$699

Bay Shore Insurance Rates by Make

Bay Shore Acura Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Acura ZDX is $1335 compared to Acura RDX (+$240) Acura TSX (+$80) & Acura MDX (+$240).

Bay Shore rates for Acura TL models such as TL, Advance, Tech, SH, SH Advance & SH Tech are nearly $1223 to $1402. The rates for a car such as 2008 Acura TL SH Advance 4 Door Sedan AWD would be about $1340 which is about 6% of the total cost of a car.

Bay Shore Audi Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Audi S5 3.0 Quattro is $1555 compared to Audi A5 (+$230) Audi A7 (+$80) & Audi Q5 (+$300).

Bay Shore rates for Audi A4 models such as 2.0T Quattro & 2.0T are nearly $1272 to $1288. A 2009 Audi A4 2.0T 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1270 & differs from nearby places such as Centereach (-$260), Village of the Branch (+$430), Setauket-East Setauket (+$460), Northport (+$500) and Amityville (+$530).

ModelsInsurance RateLevittownPoquottAsharokenBellmore
Q7$1510+$410-$490-$560-$560
TTS$1510+$410-$490-$560-$560
TT$1440+$390-$460-$540-$540
S4$1500+$400-$480-$560-$560
A3$1220+$330-$390-$460-$460
A6$1480+$400-$480-$550-$550
A8$1780+$480-$570-$660-$660

Bay Shore BMW Insurance

Bay Shore rates for BMW 5 series models such as 528i, GT, 535i & 550i are around $1289 to $1568 compared to BMW 6 series (-$1110) BMW 7 series (-$430) & BMW 3 series (-$10).

BMW 1 series models such as 128i & 135i cost around $1209 to $1316 in Bay Shore. The rates for a car such as 2013 BMW 128i 2 Door Coupe would be about $1190 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateNew CasselNesconsetEast MassapequaBayport
Z series$1500+$210-$450-$450-$510
X series$1350+$190-$410-$410-$450
M series$1830+$250-$550-$550-$620

Bay Shore Buick Insurance

Buick Enclave insurance rate is $1070 in Bay Shore. A 2013 Buick Enclave 4 Door 2WD Utility's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1060 and differs from nearby places such as Selden (-$120), Cold Spring Harbor (+$360), Massapequa (+$400), Huntington Bay (+$400) and Plainedge (+$410).

Bay Shore rates for Buick Lacrosse models such as Premium II, Leather, Premium I, Touring & Lacrosse are nearly $1070 to $1112. A 2008 Buick Lacrosse Leather 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1060 while nearby places such as Oakdale, West Islip, Hicksville and Melville are costlier by $330, $350, $370 and $380 respectively whereas North Amityville is cheaper by $80.

Buick Regal insurance rate is $1076 in Bay Shore. The rates for a car such as 2010 Buick Regal 4 Door Sedan would be about $1060 which is about 8% of the total cost of a car.

Bay Shore Cadillac Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateGordon HeightsGreenlawnHalesitePlainedge
Escalade$1430-$60-$470-$500-$550
SRX$1200-$50-$400-$420-$470
CTS$1270-$60-$420-$450-$490

Bay Shore Chevrolet Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Chevrolet Silverado models such as 1500 LT, 1500 LTZ & 1500 Work Truck are roughly $1084 to $1053 compared to Chevrolet Corvette (-$340) Chevrolet Avalanche (-$80) & Chevrolet Malibu (-$40).

Bay Shore rates for Chevrolet Equinox models such as LS, 1LT, LS AWD, 2LT, LT AWD, LTZ, 2LT AWD & LTZ AWD are roughly $990 to $1087. The rates for a car such as 2012 Chevrolet Equinox LS 2WD 4 Door Utility would be about $980 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateMedfordNorth Bay ShoreHauppaugeBlue Point
Cruze$1110+$70+$70-$340-$360
Express$1040+$70+$70-$320-$340
Camaro$1200+$80+$80-$370-$390

Bay Shore Chrysler Insurance

Chrysler 300 models such as 300 & S cost approximately $1083 to $1198 in Bay Shore. A 2013 Chrysler 300 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1070 & varies from close by places such as Islip Terrace (-$300), Fire Island (-$280), Holtsville (-$230), North Bellport (-$50) and Old Field (+$340).

Bay Shore rates for Chrysler Town models such as & Country Touring, & Country Touring L & & Country Limited are approximately $980 to $1036. A 2011 Chrysler Town & Country Touring 4 Door Wagon's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $970 while nearby places such as West Islip and Northport are costlier by $320 and $380 respectively whereas North Great River, Levittown and Baywood are cheaper by $300, $260 and $130 respectively.

Chrysler 300C insurance rate is $1169 in Bay Shore. The rates for a car such as 2011 Chrysler 300C 4 Door Sedan would be about $1150 which is about 4% of the total cost of a car.

Chrysler 200 models such as LX, Touring & Limited cost approximately $1076 to $1122 in Bay Shore. A 2013 Chrysler 200 Touring 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1090 while nearby places such as East Massapequa, Muttontown, South Huntington, Plainedge and Northport are costlier by $330, $330, $380, $420 and $430 respectively

Bay Shore Dodge Insurance

Dodge Charger models such as SE, SXT, SRT8 & R/T cost about $1209 to $1259 in Bay Shore compared to Dodge Grand (+$270) Dodge Challenger (+$50) & Dodge Avenger (+$120).

Dodge Durango models such as SXT, Crew, R/T & Citadel cost around $1118 to $1202 in Bay Shore. The rates for a car such as 2011 Dodge Durango SXT 4 Door 2WD Wagon would be about $1100 which is about 3% of the total cost of a car.

Dodge Journey models such as SXT & Crew cost about $1023 to $1043 in Bay Shore. A 2008 Dodge Journey SXT 4 Door 2WD Wagon's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1010 and varies from close by places such as Saltaire (+$310), Bethpage (+$310), Nissequogue (+$340), Bellmore (+$380) and Babylon (+$420).

Bay Shore Ford Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Ford Fiesta models such as S & SE are roughly $1057 compared to Ford Mustang (-$200) Ford Expedition (-$110) & Ford Taurus (-$90).

ModelsInsurance RateBohemiaBaywoodEast NorthportBrookville
Flex$1130+$440+$160-$350-$360
Explorer$1100+$430+$150-$340-$350
F-150$1070+$410+$150-$330-$340
Transit$1010+$390+$140-$310-$330
Focus$1120+$430+$150-$340-$360
Fusion$1100+$430+$150-$340-$350
Edge$1080+$420+$150-$330-$350

Bay Shore GMC Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateLevittownWyandanchMuttontownDix Hills
Sierra$1170+$320-$100-$350-$450
Acadia$1070+$290-$90-$320-$420
Terrain$1010+$270-$90-$300-$390
Yukon$1130+$300-$100-$340-$440

Bay Shore Honda Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Honda Fit models such as Sport & Fit are roughly $1062 to $1049 compared to Honda Pilot (-$30) Honda Accord (-$60) & Honda Civic (-$140).

Bay Shore rates for Honda Odyssey models such as LX, EX, EX-L, Touring Elite & Touring are roughly $919 to $1061. A 2011 Honda Odyssey LX 4 Door 2WD Wagon's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $910 while nearby places such as Seaford, Poquott and West Bay Shore are costlier by $270, $290 and $320 respectively whereas West Babylon and North Bellport are cheaper by $190 and $40 respectively.

ModelsInsurance RateHuntington StationBrentwoodEast NorthportSalisbury
CR-V$1020+$320+$40-$310-$310
CR-Z$1170+$370+$50-$360-$360
Insight$1150+$360+$50-$350-$350

Bay Shore Hyundai Insurance

Hyundai Tucson models such as Limited, GL & GLS cost about $1042 to $1023 in Bay Shore compared to Hyundai Accent (-$110) Hyundai Elantra (-$140) & Hyundai Genesis (-$250).

Hyundai Sonata models such as GLS, SE & Limited cost nearly $1082 to $1153 in Bay Shore. The rates for a car such as 2011 Hyundai Sonata SE 4 Door Sedan would be about $1100 which is about 5% of the total cost of a car.

Hyundai Veloster insurance rate is $1104 in Bay Shore. Insurance for a 2009 Hyundai Veloster 2 Door Hatchback in Bay Shore is $1090 while nearby places such as Fort Salonga and Asharoken are costlier by $410 and $410 respectively whereas Bohemia, North Babylon and Brookhaven are cheaper by $420, $220 and $210 respectively.

Hyundai Equus insurance rate is $1469 in Bay Shore. Insurance for a 2012 Hyundai Equus 4 Door Sedan in Bay Shore is $1450 and varies from places such as Fire Island (-$380), Farmingdale (-$350), Coram (-$160), Lloyd Harbor (+$440) and Huntington Bay (+$550).

Bay Shore Jeep Insurance

Jeep Grand models such as Cherokee Limited, Cherokee Laredo & Cherokee Overland cost approximately $1058 to $1076 in Bay Shore. Insurance for a 2008 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2WD 4 Door Utility in Bay Shore is $1050 and varies from close by places such as West Hills (+$320), Cove Neck (+$320), Poquott (+$340), Blue Point (+$340) and Centerport (+$390).

Bay Shore rates for Jeep Compass models such as Sport & Limited are approximately $1003 to $1032. A 2013 Jeep Compass Sport 2WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $990 while nearby places such as Cold Spring Harbor, Wheatley Heights and Melville are costlier by $330, $350 and $360 respectively whereas Fire Island and Farmingville are cheaper by $260 and $170 respectively.

Jeep Patriot models such as Sport & Limited cost roughly $941 to $1016 in Bay Shore. The rates for a car such as 2008 Jeep Patriot Limited 2WD 4 Door Utility would be about $1000 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Bay Shore Kia Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Kia Soul is $1080 compared to Kia Sedona (+$30) Kia Sorento (+$20) & Kia Optima (-$90).

Bay Shore rates for Kia Sportage models such as Sportage, LX, EX & SX are around $987 to $1084. A 2010 Kia Sportage EX 2WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1040 and varies from close by places such as Huntington Station (-$330), Oakdale (+$320), East Northport (+$320), Ocean Beach (+$370) and Plainedge (+$400).

Bay Shore rates for Kia Forte models such as EX, Koup EX, SX, LX & Koup SX are approximately $1115 to $1168. Insurance for a 2011 Kia Forte Koup SX 2WD 2 Door Coupe in Bay Shore is $1150 while nearby places such as Blue Point and Eatons Neck are costlier by $370 and $450 respectively whereas Islip, Deer Park and New Cassel are cheaper by $290, $280 and $160 respectively.

Bay Shore rates for Kia Rio models such as LX, 5-door LX, 5-door SX & SX are roughly $1123 to $1158. The rates for a car such as 2009 Kia Rio 5-door SX 2WD 5 Door Hatchback would be about $1140 which is about 8% of the total cost of a car.

Bay Shore Lexus Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Lexus LS models such as 460 L & 460 are approximately $1679 to $1583 compared to Lexus ES (+$450) Lexus IS (+$320) & Lexus GX460 (+$400).

Lexus RX models such as 350 & 450h cost about $1198 to $1247 in Bay Shore. The rates for a car such as 2012 Lexus RX 350 4 Door Utility would be about $1180 which is about 5% of the total cost of a car.

Lexus GX 460 insurance rate is $1263 in Bay Shore. A 2013 Lexus GX 460 4 Door Utility AWD's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1250 while nearby places such as Smithtown and Oyster Bay are costlier by $410 and $480 respectively whereas North Babylon, Brentwood and North Bellport are cheaper by $250, $50 and $50 respectively.

Bay Shore Lincoln Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Lincoln MKS is $1268 compared to Lincoln MKZ (+$130) Lincoln MKX (+$200) & Lincoln MKT (+$130).

Bay Shore rates for Lincoln Navigator models such as Navigator & L are nearly $1293 to $1348. The rates for a car such as 2011 Lincoln Navigator 4 Door 2WD SUV Ethanol would be about $1270 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

Bay Shore Mazda Insurance

Mazda Mazda3s models such as Sport, Grand Touring & Touring cost nearly $1183 to $1163 in Bay Shore compared to Mazda Mazda6i (+$90) Mazda Mazdaspeed3 (-$30) & Mazda CX-9 (+$120).

Mazda MX5 models such as Miata Sport & Miata Grand Touring cost around $967 to $1044 in Bay Shore. A 2011 Mazda MX5 Miata Grand Touring 2WD 2 Door Convertible's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1030 is different from places such as Islip (-$260), Baywood (-$140), Oyster Bay Cove (+$370), Head of the Harbor (+$390) and Gilgo (+$400).

ModelsInsurance RateRonkonkomaBaywoodEast NorwichAmityville
Mazda3i$1150+$250+$160-$350-$480
Mazda2$1060+$230+$150-$320-$440
Mazda5$1090+$240+$150-$330-$460
Mazda6s$1190+$260+$160-$360-$500

Bay Shore Nissan Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Nissan Maxima models such as SV & S are approximately $1280 compared to Nissan Titan (+$140) Nissan Armada (+$40) & Nissan Pathfinder (+$240).

Nissan Rogue S insurance rate is $1093 in Bay Shore. A 2012 Nissan Rogue S 4WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1080 while nearby places such as Hauppauge, Greenlawn, Halesite, West Bay Shore and Sayville are costlier by $330, $360, $380, $380 and $400 respectively

Nissan Juke models such as SL, S & SV cost around $1099 to $1106 in Bay Shore. A 2009 Nissan Juke SL 4 Door Hatchback's insurance costs in Bay Shore is $1080 and differs from nearby locations such as Deer Park (-$270), Brookville (+$350), Centerport (+$400), Massapequa (+$410) and Northport (+$420).

ModelsInsurance RateHuntington StationPort Jefferson StationSalisburyGreenlawn
NV3500$1120+$350+$230-$340-$370
Altima$1270+$400+$260-$390-$420
370Z$1270+$400+$260-$390-$420
Murano$1060+$330+$220-$330-$350
Quest$1110+$350+$230-$340-$370
Versa$1080+$340+$220-$330-$360
Sentra$1210+$380+$250-$370-$400

Bay Shore Toyota Insurance

Toyota Camry models such as SE, LE & XLE cost approximately $1117 to $1130 in Bay Shore compared to Toyota 4Runner (+$30) Toyota Sienna (+$140) & Toyota Prius (+$50).

ModelsInsurance RateEast FarmingdaleTerryvilleNorth MerrickHalesite
Corolla$1110+$380+$240-$370-$390
Avalon$1100+$380+$240-$370-$390
Sequoia$1110+$380+$240-$370-$390

Bay Shore Volkswagen Insurance

Bay Shore rates for Volkswagen CC models such as VR6 4Motion, Lux & Sport are nearly $1238 to $1170 compared to Volkswagen Jetta (+$100) Volkswagen Tiguan (-$0) & Volkswagen Touareg (-$130).

Bay Shore rates for Volkswagen GTI models such as Autobahn & GTI are about $1125 to $1174. Insurance for a 2009 Volkswagen GTI Autobahn 4 Door Hatchback in Bay Shore is $1110 while nearby places such as North Bellmore, Bellport, Smithtown and Huntington Bay are costlier by $340, $370, $370 and $420 respectively whereas West Babylon is cheaper by $230.

ModelsInsurance RateIslip TerraceSaltaireAsharokenMassapequa Park
Golf$1120+$310-$340-$420-$510
Eos$1230+$340-$380-$460-$560
Passat$1100+$300-$340-$410-$500


We also offer auto insurance in these cities NY:

  • Cheap Car Insurance in Bath (Steuben County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Bayport (Suffolk County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Bayside (Queens County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Bayville (Nassau County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Beacon (Dutchess County), NY