Enter ZIP Code

Cheap Auto Insurance U.S.Cheap Car Insurance New York → Fishers Island (Suffolk County)

Looking for cheap car insurance in Fishers Island (NY)? You have come to the right place!

On our website you will see quotes and rates offered by insurance companies, as well as be able to choose and send an application online.

We know how good it is to be safe in a car while driving but various situations may happen sometimes. That's why it's better to insure your car first after buying.

What do you need to do for this? Enter your ZIP code, choose an insurance company or agency, and send your request.

Soon you'll get a reply from the company representative. We wish you a safe driving and a good mood!

We offer car insurance in Fishers Island (Suffolk County), NY:



Car Insurance Agents within 50 miles of Fishers Island, NY

DOLAN DERMOT

Bridgehampton, NY - 11932 - 1193  near Enclave Inn Bridgehampton

Call: (631) 537-0223
Get a Quote

STATE FARM INSURANCE

2228 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY - 11932 - 1193  near Butter Ln,montauk Hwy

Call: (631) 537-2622
Get a Quote

Farm Family Life Insurance

543 Montauk Hwy, East Quogue, NY - 11942 - 1194 near Montauk Hwy,walker Ave

Call: (631) 653-6127
Get a Quote


Fishers Island, NY Auto Insurance Rates

Fishers Island, NY residents can save $750 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Fishers Island car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

LowestAverageHighest
$1,180 $1,880 $10,080

Fishers Island Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Fishers Island, NY's average car insurance of $1880 differs from Old Mystic, CT (+$130), Weekapaug, RI (+$440), Groton, CT (-$658) and New York (-$511)

Fishers Island Old Mystic, CT Weekapaug, RI Groton, CT New York
Median Insurance Rates $1880 +$130 +$440 -$658 -$511

Fishers Island Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Fishers Island Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Fishers Island Fishers Island Driver Demographics Fishers Island Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Fishers Island Insurance Savings
Orient Point
Poquatuck Ln2001 Lexus ES 300 Base64 year senior$2,424$540
Bennet Rd2007 Chrysler Town and Country Touring19 year male teenager$3,629$747
The Cross Way1998 Toyota 4Runner SR517 year teenager$3,431$324
Douglas Rd2010 Honda Civic LX35 year woman$1,575$923
Willow Rd2003 Acura MDX Touring17 year female teenager$3,731$676
Midland Pl2006 Nissan 350Z Coupe50 year married man$2,357$680
Golfview Ct2011 Chevrolet Express LT 350065 year male senior$2,175$857
Bight Rd2008 GMC Sierra 1500 Work Truck69 year female senior$1,841$979
Aquaview Ave2010 Mazda MAZDA6 s Touring Plus48 year man$2,394$709
Pheasant Pl2012 Hyundai Tucson GLS31 year married woman$1,623$475

Fishers Island Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Fishers Island Stonington, CT County subdivisions not defined, CT Conning Towers Nautilus Park, CT New York
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $3496 -$1041 +$930 +$186 -$950
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $7376 -$2196 +$1963 +$393 -$2005
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $6852 -$2041 +$1823 +$364 -$1862

The Post DUI insurance in Fishers Island, NY's is $3496 compared to Stonington, CT (-$1041), County subdivisions not defined, CT (+$930), Conning Towers Nautilus Park, CT (+$186) and New York (-$950)

In Fishers Island, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $524 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 1998 Toyota 4Runner SR5 in Fishers Island, NY would pay $6601 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $6130.

Fishers Island Car Insurance by Segment

Fishers Island Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

26 Fishers Island Teenagers (8% of total population), 38% Male & 62% Female.

Fishers Island Weekapaug, RI New London, CT County subdivisions not defined, CT New York
All Teenagers $3835 +$897 -$1334 +$1020 -$1043
Male Teenager $3966 +$929 -$1380 +$1055 -$1078
Female Teenager $3684 +$863 -$1282 +$980 -$1001

Fishers Island teenagers pay $3835 in insurance in contrast with Weekapaug, RI (+$897), New London, CT (-$1334), County subdivisions not defined, CT (+$1020) and New York (-$1043). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Fishers Island is $282

Example

  • 2013 Dodge Grand Caravan SE Male Teenager Insurance Rate $3,808
  • 2014 Kia Optima LX Female Teenager Insurance Rate $3,347

Fishers Island Men & Women Car Insurance

307 Fishers Island Adults (100% of total population), 45% Men & 55% Women.

Fishers Island Old Mystic, CT Westerly, RI Watch Hill, RI New York
All Women $1748 +$121 -$353 +$428 -$475
Married Women $1692 +$117 -$342 +$414 -$460
All Men $2613 +$180 -$528 +$639 -$711
Married Men $2519 +$174 -$509 +$616 -$685

The typical insurance rate of $2613 that Fishers Island Men pay varies from Old Mystic, CT (+$180), Westerly, RI (-$528), Watch Hill, RI (+$639) and New York (-$711). In Fishers Island, married men pay $827 more than married women.

Example

  • 2011 Lincoln MKS Base Married Men Insurance Rate $2,153
  • 2014 Volkswagen Tiguan SEL Married Women Insurance Rate $2,393

Fishers Island Senior Car Insurance

82 Fishers Island Seniors (26% of total population), 37% Senior Men & 63% Senior Women.

Fishers Island Noank, CT Groton Long Point, CT Weekapaug, RI New York
All Seniors $2124 -$881 +$542 +$497 -$578
Senior Men $2256 -$936 +$576 +$528 -$614
Senior Women $1955 -$811 +$499 +$457 -$532

Fishers Island seniors pay $2124 in insurance compared to Noank, CT (-$881), Groton Long Point, CT (+$542), Weekapaug, RI (+$497) and New York (-$578). In Fishers Island, senior men pay $301 more than senior women.

Fishers Island Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Fishers Island Population with 1 Vehicle 58 (40% of Fishers Island population), 2 Vehicles 50 (34% of the Fishers Island population) and 3 vehicles 19 (13% of the population)

Fishers Island Mashantucket, CT Old Mystic, CT Misquamicut, RI New York
2 Vehicles $3572 -$323 +$247 +$874 -$970
3 Vehicles $5452 -$493 +$377 +$1334 -$1481
4 Vehicles $7332 -$663 +$507 +$1794 -$1992

Fishers Island Insurance Rates by Make

Fishers Island Acura Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Acura TSX models such as Sport Wagon, Sport Wagon Tech, Tech & TSX are about $1842 to $1849 compared to Acura TL (-$140) Acura RDX (+$250) & Acura ZDX (-$120).

Acura MDX insurance rate is $1694 in Fishers Island. A 2012 Acura MDX 5 Door 4WD Utility's insurance costs in Fishers Island is $1670 while nearby places such as East Marion, Voluntown, CT, South Windham, CT and New Shoreham, RI are costlier by $510, $730, $960 and $1230 respectively whereas Mystic, CT is cheaper by $400.

Fishers Island Audi Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Audi S4 3.0 Quattro is $2370 compared to Audi S5 (-$90) Audi A3 (+$440) & Audi A8 (-$450).

Audi A6 models such as 2.0T & 3.0 Quattro cost around $2029 to $2338 in Fishers Island. The rates for a car such as 2012 Audi A6 2.0T 4 Door Sedan would be about $2000 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Audi TTS 2.0 Quattro insurance rate is $2337 in Fishers Island. Insurance for a 2012 Audi TTS 2.0 Quattro 2 Door Coupe AWD in Fishers Island is $2300 compared to places such as Preston, CT (+$540), Wainscott (+$710), Lisbon, CT (+$980), County subdivisions not defined, CT (+$1700) and Windham, CT (+$1730).

ModelsInsurance RateMystic, CTNorwich, CTNorth SeaQuonochontaug, RI
Q5$2000+$480+$170-$640-$1370
Q7$2380+$570+$200-$770-$1640
TT$2270+$550+$190-$730-$1560
A5$2100+$500+$180-$680-$1440
A4$2040+$490+$170-$660-$1400
A7$2350+$560+$200-$760-$1620

Fishers Island BMW Insurance

Fishers Island rates for BMW Z series models such as 28i sDRIVE, 35i sDRIVE & 35is sDRIVE are nearly $1989 to $2364 compared to BMW 6 series (-$1700) BMW 1 series (+$360) & BMW 7 series (-$630).

Fishers Island rates for BMW 5 series models such as 528i, GT, 535i & 550i are roughly $2037 to $2477. Insurance for a 2013 BMW 535xi GT 4 Door Sedan in Fishers Island is $2200 & differs from nearby locations such as Stonington, CT (-$80), Willimantic, CT (+$1430), Lyme, CT (+$1450), Watch Hill, RI (+$1560) and County subdivisions not defined, CT (+$1620).

ModelsInsurance RateSouth Kingstown, RINorth SeaSoutholdShelter Island
3 series$2330+$510-$750-$780-$820
X series$2140+$470-$690-$720-$750
M series$2890+$630-$930-$970-$1020

Fishers Island Buick Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateMiddlesex County, CTSagaponackWillimantic, CTNarragansett Pier, RI
Lacrosse$1730-$340-$620-$1130-$1190
Enclave$1730-$340-$620-$1130-$1190
Regal$1700-$340-$610-$1110-$1170

Fishers Island Cadillac Insurance

Cadillac CTS models such as Luxury, Premium, CTS, Performance & V cost approximately $1936 to $2346 in Fishers Island. Insurance for a 2010 Cadillac CTS Performance 2 Door Coupe in Fishers Island is $2030 while nearby places such as Hope Valley, RI, Westerly, RI, Scotland, CT and Poquonock Bridge, CT are costlier by $130, $190, $820 and $1440 respectively whereas Kingston, RI is cheaper by $380.

Fishers Island rates for Cadillac SRX models such as SRX, Performance Turbo AWD, Luxury, Performance, Premium & Premium Turbo AWD are nearly $1752 to $1952. The rates for a car such as 2008 Cadillac SRX Performance Turbo AWD 4 Door Utility would be about $1860 which is about 5% of the total cost of a car.

Cadillac Escalade models such as Escalade, Luxury, ESV, Premium, EXT, ESV Luxury, EXT Luxury, EXT Premium, ESV Premium, Platinum, Hybrid, ESV Platinum & Platinum Hybrid cost approximately $2156 to $2558 in Fishers Island. A 2013 Cadillac Escalade EXT 4 Door Utility Ethanol's insurance costs in Fishers Island is $2210 and is in contrast with nearby locations such as South Kingstown, RI (-$480), Washington County, RI (-$190), North Stonington, CT (+$420), Bozrah, CT (+$790) and Coventry, RI (+$810).

Fishers Island Chevrolet Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Chevrolet Equinox models such as LTZ, 1LT, LS AWD, 2LT AWD, LT AWD, 2LT, LS & LTZ AWD are nearly $1656 to $1717 compared to Chevrolet Corvette (-$590) Chevrolet Camaro (-$240) & Chevrolet Avalanche (-$180).

Fishers Island rates for Chevrolet Cruze models such as LS, Eco, LT & LTZ are around $1694 to $1811. The rates for a car such as 2012 Chevrolet Cruze LS 4 Door Sedan would be about $1670 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateMiddlesex County, CTChester, CTOrientShelter Island Heights
Express$1650-$330-$370-$530-$640
Malibu$1760-$350-$400-$570-$680
Silverado$1710-$340-$390-$550-$660

Fishers Island Chrysler Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateMiddlesex County, CTEast HamptonWauregan, CTJewett City, CT
300$1800-$360-$580-$1180-$1330
200$1770-$350-$570-$1160-$1310
Town$1580-$310-$510-$1040-$1170
300C$1850-$370-$600-$1220-$1370

Fishers Island Dodge Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Dodge Durango models such as Citadel, R/T, SXT & Crew are around $1899 to $1804 compared to Dodge Grand (+$240) Dodge Avenger (-$0) & Dodge Charger (-$190).

Dodge Challenger models such as SXT, R/T & SRT8 cost approximately $1888 to $2176 in Fishers Island. The rates for a car such as 2009 Dodge Challenger SRT8 2 Door Coupe would be about $2140 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Fishers Island rates for Dodge Journey models such as SXT & Crew are nearly $1616 to $1647. Insurance for a 2011 Dodge Journey SXT 4 Door 2WD Wagon in Fishers Island is $1590 compared to close by regions such as Niantic, CT (+$360), Preston, CT (+$370), Cutchogue (+$540), Shelter Island (+$560) and Canterbury, CT (+$660).

Fishers Island Ford Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Ford Taurus models such as Limited, SHO AWD, SEL AWD, Limited AWD, SEL & SE are roughly $1809 to $1693 compared to Ford Mustang (-$180) Ford Transit (+$210) & Ford Expedition (-$30).

Fishers Island rates for Ford Focus models such as SE, S & Titanium are roughly $1700 to $1847. A 2012 Ford Focus SE 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Fishers Island is $1680 while nearby places such as Westerly, RI, Peconic, Lisbon, CT, Jewett City, CT and Long Hill, CT are costlier by $160, $590, $710, $1240 and $1280 respectively

ModelsInsurance RateShelter Island HeightsScotland, CTNarragansett Pier, RICounty subdivisions not defined, CT
Flex$1790-$690-$720-$1230-$1320
Explorer$1730-$670-$700-$1190-$1280
F-150$1680-$650-$680-$1150-$1240
Fiesta$1670-$650-$670-$1150-$1230
Fusion$1740-$670-$700-$1200-$1280
Edge$1710-$660-$690-$1180-$1260

Fishers Island GMC Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateWashington County, RIEast Haddam, CTBozrah, CTGroton Long Point, CT
Sierra$1860+$160-$340-$670-$1350
Acadia$1680+$150-$310-$600-$1220
Terrain$1600+$140-$290-$570-$1160
Yukon$1780+$150-$330-$640-$1290

Fishers Island Honda Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Honda Civic models such as LX & EX are roughly $1742 to $1781 compared to Honda Fit (+$220) Honda CR-Z (+$50) & Honda CR-V (+$290).

Honda Pilot models such as LX, EX & Touring cost roughly $1627 to $1792 in Fishers Island. A 2010 Honda Pilot LX 5 Door 2WD SUV's insurance costs in Fishers Island is $1600 while nearby places such as Westerly, RI, Bozrah, CT, North Haven and Shelter Island Heights are costlier by $150, $570, $610 and $620 respectively whereas Stonington, CT is cheaper by $60.

ModelsInsurance RateBradford, RIEast HamptonSterling, CTWatch Hill, RI
Accord$1760-$450-$570-$790-$1250
Insight$1820-$470-$590-$810-$1290
Odyssey$1610-$410-$520-$720-$1140

Fishers Island Hyundai Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Hyundai Veloster is $1745 compared to Hyundai Elantra (-$80) Hyundai Sonata (-$40) & Hyundai Tucson (+$130).

Hyundai Genesis models such as 2.0T Track, 2.0T, 2.0T Premium, Genesis, 3.8 Grand Touring, 3.8 Track & R-Spec cost approximately $1881 to $2026 in Fishers Island. The rates for a car such as 2010 Hyundai Genesis 3.8 Grand Touring 2 Door Coupe would be about $1970 which is about 8% of the total cost of a car.

Hyundai Equus insurance rate is $2320 in Fishers Island. Insurance for a 2009 Hyundai Equus 4 Door Sedan in Fishers Island is $2280 and varies from close by regions such as South Kingstown, RI (-$500), Wakefield-Peacedale, RI (-$130), Oxoboxo River, CT (+$1350), Lyme, CT (+$1500) and Poquonock Bridge, CT (+$1620).

Hyundai Accent models such as GS, SE & GLS cost approximately $1763 to $1804 in Fishers Island. Insurance for a 2009 Hyundai Accent SE 5 Door Hatchback in Fishers Island is $1760 while nearby places such as Niantic, CT, Water Mill, Peconic, Shelter Island Heights and Jewett City, CT are costlier by $400, $570, $620, $680 and $1300 respectively

Fishers Island Jeep Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Jeep Grand models such as Cherokee Limited, Cherokee Laredo & Cherokee Overland are around $1672 to $1701. Insurance for a 2010 Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland 4WD 4 Door Utility in Fishers Island is $1670 while nearby places such as Southold, Napeague, Saybrook Manor, CT, Plainfield, CT and Long Hill, CT are costlier by $560, $640, $1060, $1100 and $1270 respectively

Fishers Island rates for Jeep Compass models such as Sport & Limited are about $1584 to $1631. The rates for a car such as 2009 Jeep Compass Sport 2WD 4 Door Utility would be about $1560 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Fishers Island rates for Jeep Patriot models such as Sport & Limited are nearly $1487 to $1605. Insurance for a 2013 Jeep Patriot Sport 2WD 4 Door Utility in Fishers Island is $1470 & varies from close by places such as Carolina, RI (+$230), Clinton, CT (+$340), Pawcatuck, CT (+$390), Oxoboxo River, CT (+$870) and Essex, CT (+$1060).

Fishers Island Kia Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Kia Forte models such as LX, Koup EX, EX, SX & Koup SX are roughly $1831 to $1845 compared to Kia Optima (-$50) Kia Sportage (+$130) & Kia Rio (-$30).

ModelsInsurance RateGreenport WestBaltic, CTQuonochontaug, RIEssex, CT
Soul$1710-$530-$1090-$1180-$1240
Sorento$1680-$520-$1070-$1150-$1220
Sedona$1660-$510-$1060-$1140-$1200

Fishers Island Lexus Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Lexus RX models such as 350 & 450h are around $1893 to $1970 compared to Lexus IS (-$140) Lexus GX (-$30) & Lexus ES (+$60).

Lexus GX460 Premium insurance rate is $1996 in Fishers Island. Insurance for a 2010 Lexus GX460 Premium 4 Door Utility in Fishers Island is $1970 and differs from close by regions such as Greenport West (+$610), Lyme, CT (+$1300), Old Saybrook, CT (+$1330), Weekapaug, RI (+$1370) and New Shoreham, RI (+$1450).

Fishers Island rates for Lexus LS models such as 460 & 460 L are approximately $2502 to $2653. Insurance for a 2011 Lexus LS 460 L 4 Door Sedan AWD in Fishers Island is $2610 while nearby places such as Chester Center, CT, Chester, CT, Lisbon, CT and Old Saybrook Center, CT are costlier by $380, $590, $1110 and $1890 respectively whereas Kingston, RI is cheaper by $490.

Fishers Island Lincoln Insurance

Lincoln MKZ models such as MKZ & Hybrid cost around $1890 to $1948 in Fishers Island compared to Lincoln MKT (-$10) Lincoln Navigator (-$190) & Lincoln MKS (-$210).

Lincoln MKX insurance rate is $1787 in Fishers Island. A 2009 Lincoln MKX 4 Door 4WD SUV's insurance costs in Fishers Island is $1760 is different from nearby locations such as Clinton, CT (+$410), East Marion (+$540), Orient (+$570), Bridgehampton (+$630) and Napeague (+$670).

Fishers Island Mazda Insurance

Fishers Island rates for Mazda Mazdaspeed3 is $1926 compared to Mazda Mazda5 (+$200) Mazda Mazda6s (+$50) & Mazda Mazda6i (+$200).

ModelsInsurance RateWest Greenwich, RIEast Haddam, CTConning Towers Nautilus Park, CTOld Saybrook, CT
MX5$1650+$140-$300-$740-$1110
CX-9$1680+$150-$310-$750-$1130
Mazda3i$1820+$160-$330-$810-$1220
Mazda2$1680+$150-$310-$750-$1130
Mazda3s$1880+$160-$340-$840-$1260

Fishers Island Nissan Insurance

Nissan 370Z models such as 370Z & Nismo cost nearly $1967 to $2011 in Fishers Island compared to Nissan Sentra (+$90) Nissan Murano (+$330) & Nissan Versa (+$300).

Nissan Armada Platinum insurance rate is $1954 in Fishers Island. Insurance for a 2010 Nissan Armada Platinum 2WD 4 Door in Fishers Island is $1920 compared to places such as Montauk (+$630), South Windham, CT (+$1110), Madison Center, CT (+$1220), Watch Hill, RI (+$1360) and New Shoreham, RI (+$1420).

Fishers Island rates for Nissan Titan models such as SV King Cab SWB, S King Cab SWB, SV Crew Cab LWB & SV Crew Cab SWB are roughly $1741 to $1814. A 2009 Nissan Titan SV King Cab SWB 2WD 4 Door's insurance costs in Fishers Island is $1710 while nearby places such as East Lyme, CT, Griswold, CT and Essex Village, CT are costlier by $140, $910 and $1240 respectively whereas South Kingstown, RI and New London, CT are cheaper by $370 and $180 respectively.

Fishers Island rates for Nissan NV3500 models such as S & SV are roughly $1726 to $1774. The rates for a car such as 2008 Nissan NV3500 SV 2WD 2 Door Van would be about $1740 which is about 4% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateSouth Kingstown, RINoank, CTWaterford, CTSouth Windham, CT
Pathfinder$1650+$360+$320-$470-$950
Altima$2000+$440+$390-$570-$1160
Rogue$1730+$380+$340-$490-$1000
Quest$1760+$380+$350-$500-$1020
Juke$1740+$380+$340-$500-$1010
Maxima$2020+$440+$400-$580-$1170

Fishers Island Toyota Insurance

Toyota Corolla models such as L, S & LE cost around $1749 to $1752 in Fishers Island compared to Toyota 4Runner (+$30) Toyota Sienna (+$210) & Toyota Camry (-$20).

ModelsInsurance RateEast HamptonConning Towers Nautilus Park, CTSaybrook Manor, CTQuonochontaug, RI
Avalon$1730-$560-$770-$1100-$1190
Sequoia$1760-$570-$790-$1120-$1210
Prius$1680-$540-$750-$1070-$1150

Fishers Island Volkswagen Insurance

Volkswagen GTI models such as GTI & Autobahn cost nearly $1855 to $1778 in Fishers Island compared to Volkswagen CC (-$80) Volkswagen Touareg (-$290) & Volkswagen Passat (+$30).

Fishers Island rates for Volkswagen Jetta models such as S, SE, S Sport, SEL & TDI are approximately $1608 to $1889. A 2012 Volkswagen Jetta SEL 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Fishers Island is $1820 while nearby places such as Hopkinton, RI, Montauk, Deep River Center, CT, Conning Towers Nautilus Park, CT and Weekapaug, RI are costlier by $450, $600, $730, $810 and $1260 respectively

ModelsInsurance RateHope Valley, RIWesterly, RIGriswold, CTOxoboxo River, CT
Golf$1770-$120-$170-$950-$1050
Tiguan$1860-$120-$180-$990-$1100
Eos$1950-$130-$190-$1040-$1160


We also offer auto insurance in these cities NY:

  • Cheap Car Insurance in Fine (Saint Lawrence County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Fishers Landing (Jefferson County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Fishers (Ontario County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Fishkill (Dutchess County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Fishs Eddy (Delaware County), NY