Enter ZIP Code

Cheap Auto Insurance U.S.Cheap Car Insurance New York → Middle Island (Suffolk County)

Looking for cheap car insurance in Middle Island (NY)? You have come to the right place!

On our website you will see quotes and rates offered by insurance companies, as well as be able to choose and send an application online.

We know how good it is to be safe in a car while driving but various situations may happen sometimes. That's why it's better to insure your car first after buying.

What do you need to do for this? Enter your ZIP code, choose an insurance company or agency, and send your request.

Soon you'll get a reply from the company representative. We wish you a safe driving and a good mood!

We offer car insurance in Middle Island (Suffolk County), NY:



Car Insurance Agents in Middle Island, NY

Allstate Insurance

171 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY - 11953 - 1195  near Brian Ct,middle Country Rd

Call: (631) 736-3100
Get a Quote


Middle Island, NY Auto Insurance Rates

Middle Island, NY residents can save $560 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Middle Island car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

LowestAverageHighest
$880 $1,400 $7,540

Middle Island Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Middle Island, NY's average car insurance of $1400 differs from Ridge, NY (+$120), East Shoreham (+$430), Farmingville, NY (-$270) and New York (-$31)

Middle Island Ridge, NY East Shoreham Farmingville, NY New York
Median Insurance Rates $1400 +$120 +$430 -$270 -$31

Middle Island Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Middle Island Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Middle Island Middle Island Driver Demographics Middle Island Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Middle Island Insurance Savings
Siegfield Park
Pine Cone St2003 Acura MDX Touring w/Navi34 year woman$1,322$520
Coram Swezeytown Rd2006 Chrysler Town and Country Touring84 year female senior$1,327$862
Cedar Branch St2006 Toyota Camry Standard31 year man$1,747$864
Miller Place Yaphank Rd2005 Lexus ES 330 Base30 year married man$2,144$443
Charley Ln2010 Honda Civic Si74 year male senior$1,513$427
Upton
Ivy Meadow Ct2012 Mazda 6 I16 year female teenager$2,512$387
Crystal Rock Ct2006 Nissan 350Z Enthusiast18 year teenager$2,664$628
Eagle Hill Ct2012 Volkswagen Tiguan S17 year male teenager$2,789$857
Currans Rd2011 Lincoln MKS Base30 year married woman$1,295$844
Woodville Rd2014 Kia Optima LX70 year senior$1,440$909

Middle Island Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Middle Island Rocky Point Ridge Centereach New York
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $2604 -$242 +$223 -$577 -$58
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $5494 -$512 +$471 -$1218 -$123
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $5103 -$474 +$437 -$1131 -$113

The Post DUI insurance in Middle Island, NY's is $2604 compared to Rocky Point (-$242), Ridge (+$223), Centereach (-$577) and New York (-$58)

In Middle Island, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $391 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2006 Toyota Camry Standard in Middle Island, NY would pay $4932 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $4581.

Middle Island Car Insurance by Segment

Middle Island Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

435 Middle Island Teenagers (4% of total population), 48% Male & 52% Female.

Middle Island Shirley Rocky Point Coram New York
All Teenagers $2856 +$61 -$266 -$368 -$64
Male Teenager $2954 +$63 -$275 -$380 -$66
Female Teenager $2744 +$58 -$255 -$353 -$61

Middle Island teenagers pay $2856 in insurance in contrast with Shirley (+$61), Rocky Point (-$266), Coram (-$368) and New York (-$64). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Middle Island is $210

Example

  • 2012 Buick LaCrosse Premium 1 Male Teenager Insurance Rate $2,686
  • 2007 GMC Sierra 1500 SLT Female Teenager Insurance Rate $2,581

Middle Island Men & Women Car Insurance

10026 Middle Island Adults (100% of total population), 48% Men & 52% Women.

Middle Island Gordon Heights Centereach Brookhaven New York
All Women $1302 +$27 -$289 -$270 -$29
Married Women $1260 +$27 -$279 -$261 -$28
All Men $1946 +$41 -$431 -$404 -$44
Married Men $1876 +$40 -$416 -$389 -$42

The typical insurance rate of $1946 that Middle Island Men pay varies from Gordon Heights (+$41), Centereach (-$431), Brookhaven (-$404) and New York (-$44). In Middle Island, married men pay $616 more than married women.

Example

  • 2012 Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD CC Work Truck Married Men Insurance Rate $1,759
  • 2014 Hyundai Tucson Limited Married Women Insurance Rate $1,800

Middle Island Senior Car Insurance

2441 Middle Island Seniors (24% of total population), 39% Senior Men & 61% Senior Women.

Middle Island Farmingville Yaphank Shirley New York
All Seniors $1582 -$306 -$204 +$33 -$36
Senior Men $1680 -$324 -$216 +$36 -$38
Senior Women $1456 -$281 -$188 +$31 -$33

Middle Island seniors pay $1582 in insurance compared to Farmingville (-$306), Yaphank (-$204), Shirley (+$33) and New York (-$36). In Middle Island, senior men pay $224 more than senior women.

Middle Island Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Middle Island Population with 1 Vehicle 1596 (39% of Middle Island population), 2 Vehicles 1681 (41% of the Middle Island population) and 3 vehicles 500 (12% of the population)

Middle Island East Shoreham Shirley Centereach New York
2 Vehicles $2660 +$817 +$57 -$589 -$58
3 Vehicles $4060 +$1247 +$87 -$899 -$89
4 Vehicles $5460 +$1677 +$117 -$1209 -$120

Middle Island Insurance Rates by Make

Middle Island Acura Insurance

Middle Island rates for Acura TL models such as SH, Tech, TL, Advance, SH Tech & SH Advance are approximately $1589 to $1598 compared to Acura ZDX (+$20) Acura RDX (+$300) & Acura MDX (+$300).

Acura TSX models such as Sport Wagon, TSX, Sport Wagon Tech & Tech cost around $1372 to $1556 in Middle Island. A 2009 Acura TSX Sport Wagon Tech 4 Door Wagon's insurance costs in Middle Island is $1460 while nearby places such as Calverton, Poquott and West Islip are costlier by $240, $470 and $480 respectively whereas Quiogue and Islip are cheaper by $550 and $370 respectively.

Middle Island Audi Insurance

Middle Island rates for Audi A5 2.0T is $1565 compared to Audi A8 (-$530) Audi TTS (-$210) & Audi TT (-$120).

ModelsInsurance RateNorth BellportMasticNorthvillePoquott
Q5$1490+$60-$90-$450-$480
Q7$1770+$80-$100-$530-$570
S5$1830+$80-$110-$550-$590
S4$1770+$80-$100-$530-$570
A3$1440+$60-$90-$430-$460
A4$1520+$70-$90-$460-$490
A7$1750+$80-$100-$530-$560
A6$1740+$70-$100-$520-$560

Middle Island BMW Insurance

BMW 6 series models such as 650i & 640i cost about $3283 to $3024 in Middle Island compared to BMW 3 series (+$1290) BMW M series (+$870) & BMW 1 series (+$1530).

Middle Island rates for BMW 5 series models such as 528i, GT, 535i & 550i are around $1517 to $1844. The rates for a car such as 2008 BMW 528i 4 Door Sedan would be about $1490 which is about 6% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateEast IslipDeer ParkBrookhavenEast Shoreham
Z series$1760+$690+$440+$330-$590
7 series$2230+$880+$550+$420-$750
X series$1590+$630+$390+$300-$540

Middle Island Buick Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateEast MorichesStony BrookMorichesHuntington Bay
Lacrosse$1290+$470-$420-$480-$490
Enclave$1290+$470-$420-$480-$490
Regal$1270+$460-$420-$470-$480

Middle Island Cadillac Insurance

Cadillac Escalade models such as Escalade, Luxury, ESV, Premium, EXT, ESV Luxury, EXT Luxury, EXT Premium, ESV Premium, Platinum, Hybrid, ESV Platinum & Platinum Hybrid cost roughly $1605 to $1905 in Middle Island. The rates for a car such as 2010 Cadillac Escalade ESV Platinum 4 Door Utility Ethanol would be about $1850 which is about 8% of the total cost of a car.

Cadillac SRX models such as SRX, Performance Turbo AWD, Luxury, Performance, Premium & Premium Turbo AWD cost about $1304 to $1454 in Middle Island. Insurance for a 2008 Cadillac SRX Premium 4 Door Utility in Middle Island is $1420 while nearby places such as East Quogue and West Bay Shore are costlier by $440 and $500 respectively whereas Huntington Station, North Babylon and Sound Beach are cheaper by $440, $290 and $130 respectively.

Cadillac CTS models such as Luxury, Premium, CTS, Performance & V cost nearly $1441 to $1747 in Middle Island. A 2012 Cadillac CTS Premium 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Middle Island is $1460 and differs from close by places such as Bohemia (-$560), Rocky Point (-$110), North Bellport (-$60), Stratford, CT (+$440) and Jamesport (+$520).

Middle Island Chevrolet Insurance

Middle Island rates for Chevrolet Malibu models such as LS, LTZ & LT are approximately $1239 to $1313 compared to Chevrolet Express (+$80) Chevrolet Silverado (+$30) & Chevrolet Avalanche (-$60).

Chevrolet Corvette models such as Corvette, GS, Z06 & ZR1 cost about $1644 to $2722 in Middle Island. Insurance for a 2012 Chevrolet Corvette GS 2 Door Convertible in Middle Island is $1650 while nearby places such as Nesconset and Hampton Bays are costlier by $500 and $640 respectively whereas Center Moriches, Fire Island and Bay Shore are cheaper by $600, $430 and $220 respectively.

ModelsInsurance RateQuiogueSeldenWest IslipHalesite
Cruze$1310+$500+$150-$430-$460
Equinox$1230+$470+$140-$410-$430
Camaro$1410+$530+$160-$460-$500

Middle Island Chrysler Insurance

Chrysler 200 models such as Limited, LX & Touring cost around $1320 to $1293 in Middle Island compared to Chrysler 300 (-$20) Chrysler 300C (-$60) & Chrysler Town (+$150).

Middle Island Dodge Insurance

Middle Island rates for Dodge Grand Caravan SXT is $1161 compared to Dodge Charger (-$320) Dodge Avenger (-$180) & Dodge Challenger (-$260).

Dodge Durango models such as SXT, Crew, R/T & Citadel cost around $1316 to $1414 in Middle Island. The rates for a car such as 2009 Dodge Durango Citadel 4 Door 2WD Wagon would be about $1390 which is about 4% of the total cost of a car.

Middle Island rates for Dodge Journey models such as SXT & Crew are nearly $1203 to $1227. Insurance for a 2013 Dodge Journey Crew 4 Door 2WD Wagon in Middle Island is $1210 while nearby places such as Nesconset and Wading River are costlier by $360 and $430 respectively whereas Center Moriches, Islip and Coram are cheaper by $440, $310 and $130 respectively.

Middle Island Ford Insurance

Middle Island rates for Ford Fusion models such as SE, SEL & S are about $1298 to $1283 compared to Ford Explorer (+$10) Ford Taurus (-$50) & Ford Edge (+$20).

Middle Island rates for Ford Fiesta models such as S & SE are roughly $1243 to $1244. Insurance for a 2011 Ford Fiesta SE 4 Door Hatchback in Middle Island is $1230 compared to nearby places such as North Great River (-$380), Brentwood (-$50), Old Field (+$400), Bayport (+$410) and Dix Hills (+$480).

ModelsInsurance RateQuiogueStony Brook UniversityRocky PointGreat River
Flex$1330+$500+$410+$100-$470
F-150$1250+$470+$380+$90-$440
Expedition$1370+$520+$420+$100-$480
Transit$1190+$450+$360+$90-$420
Focus$1320+$500+$400+$100-$460
Mustang$1480+$560+$450+$110-$520

Middle Island GMC Insurance

Middle Island rates for GMC Acadia models such as SLT, Denali & SLE are about $1170 to $1251 compared to GMC Yukon (-$70) GMC Terrain (+$60) & GMC Sierra (-$130).

Middle Island Honda Insurance

Middle Island rates for Honda Fit models such as Sport & Fit are roughly $1249 to $1234 compared to Honda CR-V (+$50) Honda Pilot (-$30) & Honda CR-Z (-$130).

Honda Insight models such as Insight, EX & LX cost roughly $1319 to $1384 in Middle Island. Insurance for a 2009 Honda Insight LX 5 Door Hatchback in Middle Island is $1360 is different from places such as Bohemia (-$530), Islandia (-$150), Saltaire (+$420), East Quogue (+$420) and Dix Hills (+$530).

ModelsInsurance RateCentereachBay ShoreMastic BeachOak Beach-Captree
Accord$1310+$270+$170-$320-$390
Civic$1410+$290+$180-$340-$420
Odyssey$1200+$240+$160-$290-$360

Middle Island Hyundai Insurance

Hyundai Elantra models such as GLS & Limited cost roughly $1321 to $1359 in Middle Island compared to Hyundai Tucson (+$160) Hyundai Accent (+$30) & Hyundai Equus (-$370).

Hyundai Veloster insurance rate is $1299 in Middle Island. Insurance for a 2013 Hyundai Veloster 2 Door Hatchback in Middle Island is $1280 while nearby places such as Westhampton and Wading River are costlier by $380 and $450 respectively whereas Woodmont, CT, Bay Shore and Selden are cheaper by $200, $170 and $150 respectively.

Middle Island rates for Hyundai Sonata models such as GLS, SE & Limited are approximately $1273 to $1357. A 2012 Hyundai Sonata GLS 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Middle Island is $1260 & varies from close by places such as Islip (-$320), Port Jefferson (+$360), Kings Park (+$410), Sayville (+$470) and Huntington Bay (+$480).

Hyundai Genesis models such as 2.0T Track, 2.0T, 2.0T Premium, Genesis, 3.8 Grand Touring, 3.8 Track & R-Spec cost around $1401 to $1509 in Middle Island. The rates for a car such as 2012 Hyundai Genesis R-Spec 4 Door Sedan would be about $1490 which is about 8% of the total cost of a car.

Middle Island Jeep Insurance

Jeep Grand models such as Cherokee Limited, Cherokee Laredo & Cherokee Overland cost nearly $1245 to $1267 in Middle Island. A 2013 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Middle Island is $1240 compared to close by places such as Suffolk County (-$420), Riverhead (-$330), Brookhaven (-$230), Riverside (+$420) and Eastport (+$460).

Jeep Patriot models such as Sport & Limited cost nearly $1107 to $1195 in Middle Island. A 2010 Jeep Patriot Limited 2WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Middle Island is $1180 while nearby places such as Oak Beach-Captree, Manorville and Bayport are costlier by $350, $380 and $400 respectively whereas Riverhead and Yaphank are cheaper by $310 and $130 respectively.

Jeep Compass models such as Sport & Limited cost about $1180 to $1214 in Middle Island. The rates for a car such as 2011 Jeep Compass Sport 2WD 4 Door Utility would be about $1160 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

Middle Island Kia Insurance

Middle Island rates for Kia Rio models such as LX, 5-door LX, 5-door SX & SX are nearly $1321 to $1363 compared to Kia Forte (+$20) Kia Sedona (+$120) & Kia Sorento (+$110).

ModelsInsurance RateEast NorthportLake GroveOld FieldBellport
Optima$1380-$420-$440-$440-$450
Soul$1270-$390-$400-$410-$420
Sportage$1240-$380-$390-$400-$410

Middle Island Lexus Insurance

Lexus RX models such as 350 & 450h cost nearly $1410 to $1467 in Middle Island compared to Lexus IS (-$100) Lexus GX460 (-$20) & Lexus GX (-$20).

Lexus ES 350 insurance rate is $1424 in Middle Island. Insurance for a 2008 Lexus ES 350 4 Door Sedan in Middle Island is $1400 & differs from nearby locations such as Center Moriches (-$510), Islip (-$360), West Bay Shore (+$490), Sayville (+$520) and Bridgeport, CT (+$560).

Middle Island rates for Lexus LS models such as 460 & 460 L are about $1863 to $1975. The rates for a car such as 2013 Lexus LS 460 L 4 Door Sedan AWD would be about $1950 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

Middle Island Lincoln Insurance

Lincoln Navigator models such as Navigator & L cost around $1521 to $1586 in Middle Island compared to Lincoln MKT (+$140) Lincoln MKX (+$220) & Lincoln MKZ (+$140).

Lincoln MKS insurance rate is $1492 in Middle Island. The rates for a car such as 2012 Lincoln MKS 4 Door Sedan would be about $1470 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

Middle Island Mazda Insurance

Mazda Mazda3s models such as Sport, Grand Touring & Touring cost nearly $1392 to $1369 in Middle Island compared to Mazda Mazda6s (-$0) Mazda Mazda3i (+$40) & Mazda Mazdaspeed3 (-$30).

ModelsInsurance RateBay ShoreBlue PointWesthampton BeachSetauket-East Setauket
MX5$1230+$160-$400-$430-$440
CX-9$1250+$160-$400-$440-$450
Mazda2$1250+$160-$400-$440-$450
Mazda5$1290+$170-$420-$450-$460
Mazda6i$1290+$170-$420-$450-$460

Middle Island Nissan Insurance

Middle Island rates for Nissan Titan models such as S King Cab SWB, SV Crew Cab LWB, SV King Cab SWB & SV Crew Cab SWB are approximately $1297 to $1350 compared to Nissan Rogue (+$60) Nissan Pathfinder (+$120) & Nissan Sentra (-$80).

Nissan Maxima models such as SV & S cost around $1506 in Middle Island. The rates for a car such as 2011 Nissan Maxima SV 4 Door Sedan would be about $1480 which is about 6% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateMasticEast NorthportMattituckCenterport
NV3500$1320-$80-$410-$470-$490
Altima$1490-$90-$460-$530-$560
370Z$1500-$90-$460-$540-$560
Murano$1250-$70-$380-$450-$470
Quest$1310-$80-$400-$470-$490
Versa$1270-$80-$390-$460-$470
Armada$1460-$90-$450-$520-$540
Juke$1300-$80-$400-$470-$490

Middle Island Toyota Insurance

Toyota Corolla models such as L, S & LE cost approximately $1302 to $1304 in Middle Island compared to Toyota 4Runner (+$20) Toyota Sequoia (-$10) & Toyota Avalon (+$10).

ModelsInsurance RateEast MorichesSouth HuntingtonMount SinaiMoriches
Sienna$1150+$420-$400-$430-$430
Camry$1320+$480-$460-$490-$490
Prius$1250+$460-$440-$470-$470

Middle Island Volkswagen Insurance

Volkswagen Passat models such as SE, TDI SEL, SEL & S cost nearly $1209 to $1194 in Middle Island compared to Volkswagen Jetta (+$30) Volkswagen CC (-$80) & Volkswagen GTI (-$20).

Middle Island rates for Volkswagen Touareg models such as Touareg, TDI & Hybrid are nearly $1366 to $1587. The rates for a car such as 2013 Volkswagen Touareg 4WD 4 Door Utility would be about $1350 which is about 8% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateIslip TerraceOld FieldGreenlawnBrightwaters
Golf$1320+$370-$430-$430-$440
Tiguan$1380+$380-$440-$450-$460
Eos$1450+$400-$470-$480-$490


We also offer auto insurance in these cities NY:

  • Cheap Car Insurance in Middle Grove (Saratoga County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Middle Village (Queens County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Middleburgh (Schoharie County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Middleport (Niagara County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Middlesex (Yates County), NY