Enter ZIP Code

Looking for cheap car insurance in Phelps (NY)? You have come to the right place!

On our website you will see quotes and rates offered by insurance companies, as well as be able to choose and send an application online.

We know how good it is to be safe in a car while driving but various situations may happen sometimes. That's why it's better to insure your car first after buying.

What do you need to do for this? Enter your ZIP code, choose an insurance company or agency, and send your request.

Soon you'll get a reply from the company representative. We wish you a safe driving and a good mood!

We offer car insurance in Phelps (Ontario County), NY:



Car Insurance Agents in Phelps, NY

Nationwide Insurance

989 State Route 96 , Phelps, NY - 14532 - 1453 near Pre Emption Rd,state Highway 96

Call: (315) 548-2764
Get a Quote

Nationwide Insurance - Richard P Rockefeller

1558 Rockefeller Rd, Phelps, NY - 14532 - 1453  near Marbletown Rd,rockefeller Rd

Call: (315) 548-9457
Get a Quote


Phelps, NY Auto Insurance Rates

Phelps, NY residents can save $720 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Phelps car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

LowestAverageHighest
$1,140 $1,810 $9,710

Phelps Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Phelps, NY's average car insurance of $1810 differs from Canandaigua, NY (-$853), Galen, NY (+$50), Hall, NY (+$10) and New York (-$441)

Phelps Canandaigua, NY Galen, NY Hall, NY New York
Median Insurance Rates $1810 -$853 +$50 +$10 -$441

Phelps Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Phelps Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Phelps Phelps Driver Demographics Phelps Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Phelps Insurance Savings
Phelps Junction
Sherman St2004 Mazda MAZDA3 i72 year female senior$1,724$512
Wilber Rd2006 Lexus ES 330 Base16 year teenager$4,226$752
State Rte 882009 Toyota Corolla XLE62 year male senior$1,948$333
Lake Rd2010 Chrysler Town and Country LX21 year man$2,299$965
Waddell Rd2013 Honda Civic U.S. LX72 year senior$1,839$624
Cedar Swamp Rd2012 GMC Sierra 1500 SL17 year female teenager$3,343$595
Thompson Station Rd2010 Lincoln MKS Base45 year woman$1,730$340
Sanitarium Rd2014 Kia Optima LX18 year male teenager$3,477$399
Pelis Rd2013 Dodge Grand Caravan SE49 year married man$2,339$627
Eagle St2013 Ford Fusion SE35 year married woman$1,527$855

Phelps Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Phelps Hopewell Clyde Hall New York
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $3366 +$19 +$149 +$19 -$820
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $7103 +$39 +$312 +$39 -$1732
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $6597 +$37 +$292 +$37 -$1607

The Post DUI insurance in Phelps, NY's is $3366 compared to Hopewell (+$19), Clyde (+$149), Hall (+$19) and New York (-$820)

In Phelps, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $506 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2009 Toyota Corolla XLE in Phelps, NY would pay $6372 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $5920.

Phelps Car Insurance by Segment

Phelps Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

469 Phelps Teenagers (6% of total population), 54% Male & 46% Female.

Phelps Lyons Manchester Clyde New York
All Teenagers $3692 +$163 +$20 +$163 -$900
Male Teenager $3819 +$168 +$21 +$168 -$931
Female Teenager $3547 +$157 +$20 +$157 -$864

Phelps teenagers pay $3692 in insurance in contrast with Lyons (+$163), Manchester (+$20), Clyde (+$163) and New York (-$900). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Phelps is $272

Example

  • 2009 Nissan 370Z Touring Male Teenager Insurance Rate $3,572
  • 2014 Hyundai Tucson SE Female Teenager Insurance Rate $3,404

Phelps Men & Women Car Insurance

7048 Phelps Adults (100% of total population), 49% Men & 51% Women.

Phelps Newark Seneca Clyde New York
All Women $1683 -$817 +$9 +$74 -$410
Married Women $1629 -$791 +$9 +$72 -$397
All Men $2515 -$1220 +$14 +$112 -$613
Married Men $2425 -$1177 +$13 +$107 -$591

The typical insurance rate of $2515 that Phelps Men pay varies from Newark (-$1220), Seneca (+$14), Clyde (+$112) and New York (-$613). In Phelps, married men pay $796 more than married women.

Example

  • 2008 Cadillac Escalade EXT Base Married Men Insurance Rate $2,077
  • 2013 Volkswagen Tiguan SEL Married Women Insurance Rate $2,299

Phelps Senior Car Insurance

1595 Phelps Seniors (22% of total population), 49% Senior Men & 51% Senior Women.

Phelps Arcadia Geneva Galen New York
All Seniors $2045 +$11 -$995 +$56 -$499
Senior Men $2172 +$12 -$1056 +$60 -$530
Senior Women $1882 +$10 -$915 +$52 -$459

Phelps seniors pay $2045 in insurance compared to Arcadia (+$11), Geneva (-$995), Galen (+$56) and New York (-$499). In Phelps, senior men pay $290 more than senior women.

Phelps Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Phelps Population with 1 Vehicle 892 (31% of Phelps population), 2 Vehicles 1106 (38% of the Phelps population) and 3 vehicles 591 (20% of the population)

Phelps Waterloo Manchester Arcadia New York
2 Vehicles $3439 -$1626 +$19 +$19 -$837
3 Vehicles $5249 -$2482 +$29 +$29 -$1278
4 Vehicles $7059 -$3338 +$39 +$39 -$1719

Phelps Insurance Rates by Make

Phelps Acura Insurance

Phelps rates for Acura ZDX is $2030 compared to Acura RDX (+$360) Acura TL (-$20) & Acura MDX (+$360).

Acura TSX models such as Sport Wagon, TSX, Sport Wagon Tech & Tech cost approximately $1774 to $2012 in Phelps. The rates for a car such as 2011 Acura TSX Sport Wagon 4 Door Wagon would be about $1750 which is about 8% of the total cost of a car.

Phelps Audi Insurance

Audi A4 models such as 2.0T & 2.0T Quattro cost about $1959 to $1935 in Phelps compared to Audi S5 (-$410) Audi TTS (-$340) & Audi Q5 (+$40).

ModelsInsurance RateGenevaPort ByronSterlingHemlock
Q7$2290+$730-$690-$770-$890
TT$2190+$700-$660-$740-$850
S4$2280+$730-$680-$770-$880
A3$1860+$600-$560-$630-$720
A5$2020+$650-$610-$680-$780
A7$2260+$720-$680-$760-$880
A6$2250+$720-$680-$760-$870
A8$2710+$870-$810-$910-$1050

Phelps BMW Insurance

Phelps rates for BMW 1 series models such as 135i & 128i are roughly $2003 to $1839 compared to BMW M series (-$850) BMW Z series (-$350) & BMW 3 series (-$310).

Phelps rates for BMW 5 series models such as 528i, GT, 535i & 550i are around $1962 to $2385. The rates for a car such as 2011 BMW 535i 4 Door Sedan would be about $2180 which is about 10% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateAuburnMendonPotterPrattsburgh
7 series$2880+$820-$510-$1010-$1100
6 series$3910+$1120-$690-$1370-$1490
X series$2060+$590-$360-$720-$780

Phelps Buick Insurance

Buick Enclave insurance rate is $1627 in Phelps. Insurance for a 2011 Buick Enclave 4 Door 2WD Utility in Phelps is $1600 while nearby places such as Pittsford, Cayuga County, South Bristol, Crystal Beach and Wolcott are costlier by $210, $490, $500, $540 and $570 respectively

Buick Lacrosse models such as Premium II, Leather, Premium I, Touring & Lacrosse cost around $1627 to $1692 in Phelps. The rates for a car such as 2009 Buick Lacrosse Touring 4 Door Sedan would be about $1640 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

Buick Regal insurance rate is $1636 in Phelps. A 2013 Buick Regal 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Phelps is $1610 & differs from nearby locations such as Newark (-$510), Butler (+$480), Junius (+$500), Springport (+$500) and Wolcott (+$580).

Phelps Cadillac Insurance

Cadillac SRX models such as SRX, Performance Turbo AWD, Luxury, Performance, Premium & Premium Turbo AWD cost nearly $1687 to $1880 in Phelps. A 2010 Cadillac SRX Performance 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Phelps is $1800 while nearby places such as Marion, Weedsport, Italy, Aurelius and Gorham are costlier by $540, $590, $610, $610 and $650 respectively

Phelps rates for Cadillac CTS models such as Luxury, Premium, CTS, Performance & V are around $1864 to $2259. The rates for a car such as 2008 Cadillac CTS V 2 Door Coupe would be about $2220 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

Cadillac Escalade models such as Escalade, Luxury, ESV, Premium, EXT, ESV Luxury, EXT Luxury, EXT Premium, ESV Premium, Platinum, Hybrid, ESV Platinum & Platinum Hybrid cost about $2075 to $2463 in Phelps. A 2010 Cadillac Escalade ESV Platinum 4 Door Utility Ethanol's insurance costs in Phelps is $2390 is different from nearby places such as Rochester (-$640), Springport (+$730), Aurelius (+$800), Clyde (+$910) and Starkey (+$930).

Phelps Chevrolet Insurance

Chevrolet Equinox models such as LTZ, 1LT, LS AWD, 2LT AWD, LT AWD, 2LT, LS & LTZ AWD cost nearly $1594 to $1653 in Phelps compared to Chevrolet Express (+$10) Chevrolet Corvette (-$580) & Chevrolet Cruze (-$100).

Chevrolet Camaro models such as LS, LT & SS cost about $1718 to $1930 in Phelps. The rates for a car such as 2013 Chevrolet Camaro SS 2 Door Coupe would be about $1900 which is about 4% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateAuburnHoneoyeSterlingWilliamson
Malibu$1700+$490-$520-$570-$600
Avalanche$1770+$510-$540-$600-$620
Silverado$1650+$470-$510-$560-$580

Phelps Chrysler Insurance

ModelsInsurance RatePort ByronScipioKeuka ParkHenrietta
300$1730-$520-$530-$670-$670
200$1710-$510-$530-$660-$660
Town$1520-$460-$470-$590-$590
300C$1780-$530-$550-$690-$690

Phelps Dodge Insurance

Dodge Challenger models such as SRT8, SXT & R/T cost around $2095 to $1836 in Phelps compared to Dodge Journey (+$250) Dodge Durango (+$100) & Dodge Avenger (+$100).

Dodge Charger models such as SXT, SE, R/T & SRT8 cost around $1829 to $2315 in Phelps. The rates for a car such as 2009 Dodge Charger SE 4 Door Sedan would be about $1810 which is about 3% of the total cost of a car.

Dodge Grand Caravan SXT insurance rate is $1501 in Phelps. A 2013 Dodge Grand Caravan SXT 2WD 4 Door Van's insurance costs in Phelps is $1480 while nearby places such as Montezuma and Throop are costlier by $520 and $550 respectively whereas Fairport, Geneva and Waterloo are cheaper by $550, $470 and $450 respectively.

Phelps Ford Insurance

Phelps rates for Ford F-150 XLT is $1553 compared to Ford Flex (-$100) Ford Transit (+$80) & Ford Fiesta (+$10).

Ford Fusion models such as S, SE & SEL cost nearly $1659 to $1743 in Phelps. Insurance for a 2013 Ford Fusion SEL 4 Door Sedan in Phelps is $1720 is different from close by places such as Brutus (+$520), Conquest (+$530), Naples (+$570), Shortsville (+$600) and Jordan (+$670).

ModelsInsurance RateJerusalemWalworthMentzPultneyville
Explorer$1670-$500-$550-$590-$590
Expedition$1780-$530-$590-$630-$630
Focus$1700-$510-$560-$600-$600
Taurus$1740-$520-$570-$610-$610
Edge$1650-$500-$540-$580-$580
Mustang$1920-$580-$630-$670-$670

Phelps GMC Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateButlerDundeeJordanKeuka Park
Sierra$1790-$540-$630-$690-$690
Acadia$1620-$490-$570-$630-$630
Terrain$1540-$460-$540-$600-$600
Yukon$1710-$510-$600-$660-$660

Phelps Honda Insurance

Phelps rates for Honda Insight models such as EX, LX & Insight are nearly $1749 to $1705 compared to Honda Accord (+$50) Honda Fit (+$130) & Honda CR-V (+$200).

Phelps rates for Honda Civic models such as LX & EX are nearly $1677 to $1714. Insurance for a 2011 Honda Civic LX 4 Door Sedan in Phelps is $1650 in contrast with close by places such as Livonia Center (+$500), Conquest (+$510), Shortsville (+$580), Potter (+$580) and Henrietta (+$640).

ModelsInsurance RateRochesterAureliusLodiSeneca County
CR-Z$1780+$480-$600-$660-$690
Odyssey$1550+$420-$520-$580-$600
Pilot$1660+$450-$560-$620-$640

Phelps Hyundai Insurance

Hyundai Elantra models such as GLS & Limited cost about $1708 to $1757 in Phelps compared to Hyundai Accent (+$40) Hyundai Veloster (+$80) & Hyundai Tucson (+$200).

Phelps rates for Hyundai Sonata models such as GLS, SE & Limited are approximately $1646 to $1754. Insurance for a 2013 Hyundai Sonata Limited 4 Door Sedan Turbo in Phelps is $1730 while nearby places such as Scipio, Meridian, Weedsport, Shortsville and Irondequoit are costlier by $530, $530, $570, $610 and $660 respectively

Hyundai Genesis models such as 2.0T Track, 2.0T, 2.0T Premium, Genesis, 3.8 Grand Touring, 3.8 Track & R-Spec cost around $1811 to $1951 in Phelps. Insurance for a 2008 Hyundai Genesis 4 Door Sedan in Phelps is $1800 & differs from places such as Meridian (+$550), Hall (+$590), Montezuma (+$630), Gorham (+$650) and Throop (+$670).

Hyundai Equus insurance rate is $2234 in Phelps. The rates for a car such as 2010 Hyundai Equus 4 Door Sedan would be about $2200 which is about 6% of the total cost of a car.

Phelps Jeep Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateMendonMarionCovertFayette
Patriot$1550-$270-$470-$520-$580
Grand$1620-$290-$490-$550-$600
Compass$1570-$280-$470-$530-$590

Phelps Kia Insurance

Phelps rates for Kia Rio models such as LX, 5-door LX, 5-door SX & SX are roughly $1708 to $1762 compared to Kia Optima (-$20) Kia Sedona (+$160) & Kia Soul (+$120).

ModelsInsurance RateNaplesHallCrystal BeachDundee
Sportage$1610-$530-$530-$540-$570
Forte$1730-$570-$570-$580-$610
Sorento$1620-$530-$530-$550-$570

Phelps Lexus Insurance

Lexus LS models such as 460 L & 460 cost nearly $2554 to $2408 in Phelps compared to Lexus RX (+$620) Lexus ES (+$680) & Lexus GX (+$600).

Lexus GX460 Premium insurance rate is $1922 in Phelps. The rates for a car such as 2012 Lexus GX460 Premium 4 Door Utility would be about $1900 which is about 7% of the total cost of a car.

Phelps rates for Lexus IS models such as 250, 250C, 350, 350C, 350 AWD & F are nearly $1869 to $3066. Insurance for a 2011 Lexus IS 250C 2 Door Convertible in Phelps is $2000 while nearby places such as Arcadia, Williamson, Lima, South Lima and Starkey are costlier by $660, $700, $760, $760 and $780 respectively

Phelps Lincoln Insurance

Phelps rates for Lincoln MKT is $1828 compared to Lincoln Navigator (-$180) Lincoln MKX (+$110) & Lincoln MKS (-$190).

Phelps rates for Lincoln MKZ models such as MKZ & Hybrid are nearly $1820 to $1876. A 2010 Lincoln MKZ 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Phelps is $1790 and varies from nearby places such as Mendon (+$320), Port Byron (+$540), Honeoye (+$550), Dundee (+$630) and Gorham (+$640).

Phelps Mazda Insurance

Phelps rates for Mazda Mazda3s models such as Sport, Grand Touring & Touring are roughly $1800 to $1770 compared to Mazda Mazdaspeed3 (-$40) Mazda CX-9 (+$190) & Mazda Mazda3i (+$50).

ModelsInsurance RateFairportVictorWeedsportGorham
MX5$1590+$590-$400-$520-$570
Mazda2$1620+$600-$400-$530-$580
Mazda5$1660+$610-$410-$550-$600
Mazda6s$1810+$670-$450-$600-$650
Mazda6i$1670+$620-$420-$550-$600

Phelps Nissan Insurance

Phelps rates for Nissan NV3500 models such as S & SV are approximately $1661 to $1708 compared to Nissan Quest (+$20) Nissan Armada (-$170) & Nissan Maxima (-$240).

Nissan Pathfinder models such as S & SV cost around $1478 to $1601 in Phelps. A 2009 Nissan Pathfinder S 2WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Phelps is $1460 while nearby places such as Jerusalem, Sodus, Wolcott and Clyde are costlier by $440, $440, $520 and $560 respectively whereas Penn Yan is cheaper by $440.

ModelsInsurance RateJerusalemHallLivoniaSennett
Altima$1930-$580-$640-$650-$690
Rogue$1660-$500-$550-$560-$600
Titan$1740-$520-$570-$590-$620
370Z$1940-$580-$640-$650-$700
Murano$1620-$490-$530-$550-$580
Versa$1640-$490-$540-$550-$590
Juke$1680-$500-$550-$570-$600
Sentra$1850-$560-$610-$620-$660

Phelps Toyota Insurance

Toyota Sequoia models such as Platinum, SR5 & Limited cost nearly $1689 to $1681 in Phelps compared to Toyota Avalon (+$20) Toyota Prius (+$70) & Toyota 4Runner (+$30).

Phelps rates for Toyota Camry models such as LE, SE & XLE are about $1672 to $1720. Insurance for a 2008 Toyota Camry XLE 4 Door Sedan in Phelps is $1690 and differs from nearby places such as Torrey (+$510), Honeoye Falls (+$520), Bristol (+$560), Richmond (+$570) and Pultneyville (+$590).

Phelps rates for Toyota Corolla models such as L, LE & S are nearly $1684 to $1694. The rates for a car such as 2009 Toyota Corolla S 4 Door Sedan would be about $1670 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Toyota Sienna insurance rate is $1486 in Phelps. Insurance for a 2009 Toyota Sienna 5 Door Wagon in Phelps is $1460 while nearby places such as Victor, Hopewell, Fleming, Sennett and Red Creek are costlier by $360, $480, $490, $520 and $520 respectively

Phelps Volkswagen Insurance

Phelps rates for Volkswagen Jetta models such as TDI, S Sport, SE, S & SEL are approximately $1819 to $1772 compared to Volkswagen GTI (-$70) Volkswagen Passat (-$40) & Volkswagen CC (-$150).

Volkswagen Touareg models such as Touareg, TDI & Hybrid cost about $1766 to $2051 in Phelps. Insurance for a 2009 Volkswagen Touareg Hybrid 4WD 4 Door Utility Hybrid in Phelps is $2020 & varies from nearby locations such as Geneva (-$650), Hopewell (+$670), Hall (+$670), Naples (+$670) and Ontario (+$680).

ModelsInsurance RateHopewellRed CreekLodiIrondequoit
Golf$1700-$560-$610-$630-$650
Tiguan$1790-$590-$640-$670-$680
Eos$1880-$620-$670-$700-$720


We also offer auto insurance in these cities NY:

  • Cheap Car Insurance in Petersburg (Rensselaer County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Philadelphia (Jefferson County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Phillipsport (Sullivan County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Philmont (Columbia County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Phoenicia (Ulster County), NY