Enter ZIP Code

Cheap Auto Insurance U.S.Cheap Car Insurance New York → Shelter Island (Suffolk County)

Looking for cheap car insurance in Shelter Island (NY)? You have come to the right place!

On our website you will see quotes and rates offered by insurance companies, as well as be able to choose and send an application online.

We know how good it is to be safe in a car while driving but various situations may happen sometimes. That's why it's better to insure your car first after buying.

What do you need to do for this? Enter your ZIP code, choose an insurance company or agency, and send your request.

Soon you'll get a reply from the company representative. We wish you a safe driving and a good mood!

We offer car insurance in Shelter Island (Suffolk County), NY:



Car Insurance Agents in Shelter Island, NY

Chase Bank

48 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY - 11964 - 1196  near Thomas St,ferry Rd

Call: (631) 749-0440
Get a Quote


Shelter Island, NY Auto Insurance Rates

Shelter Island, NY residents can save $740 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Shelter Island car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

LowestAverageHighest
$1,170 $1,850 $9,930

Shelter Island Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Shelter Island, NY's average car insurance of $1850 differs from Bridgehampton, NY (+$10), East Marion (-$60), Wainscott, NY (-$60) and New York (-$481)

Shelter Island Bridgehampton, NY East Marion Wainscott, NY New York
Median Insurance Rates $1850 +$10 -$60 -$60 -$481

Shelter Island Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Shelter Island Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Shelter Island Shelter Island Driver Demographics Shelter Island Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Shelter Island Insurance Savings
Montclair Colony
Merkel Ln2003 Toyota Camry XLE18 year female teenager$3,247$505
Coecles Pl2006 Chrysler Town & Country Touring62 year senior$1,909$909
Willow Pond Rd2004 Acura MDX Touring w/Navi60 year male senior$2,250$929
Hillside Dr2012 Mazda MAZDA6 i Touring44 year married woman$1,526$970
Heron Ln2004 Nissan 350Z Enthusiast44 year man$2,400$640
Worthy Way2006 Lexus ES 330 Base34 year woman$1,973$854
Carousel Ln2012 Honda Civic LX19 year teenager$3,398$976
Waverly Pl2012 Volkswagen Tiguan S39 year married man$2,351$740
Johnston Rd2007 GMC Sierra 1500 SLT19 year male teenager$3,671$384
Pennys Path2014 Kia Optima LX77 year female senior$1,745$517

Shelter Island Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Shelter Island Amagansett New Suffolk East Marion New York
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $3441 +$18 +$55 -$112 -$895
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $7259 +$39 +$117 -$236 -$1888
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $6744 +$35 +$108 -$220 -$1754

The Post DUI insurance in Shelter Island, NY's is $3441 compared to Amagansett (+$18), New Suffolk (+$55), East Marion (-$112) and New York (-$895)

In Shelter Island, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $515 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2004 Acura MDX Touring w/Navi in Shelter Island, NY would pay $7358 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $6835.

Shelter Island Car Insurance by Segment

Shelter Island Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

239 Shelter Island Teenagers (9% of total population), 25% Male & 75% Female.

Shelter Island East Marion Sagaponack New Suffolk New York
All Teenagers $3774 -$123 +$20 +$61 -$982
Male Teenager $3903 -$127 +$21 +$63 -$1015
Female Teenager $3626 -$118 +$19 +$58 -$943

Shelter Island teenagers pay $3774 in insurance in contrast with East Marion (-$123), Sagaponack (+$20), New Suffolk (+$61) and New York (-$982). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Shelter Island is $277

Example

  • 2013 Ford Fusion SE Male Teenager Insurance Rate $3,662
  • 2012 Buick LaCrosse Premium 1 Female Teenager Insurance Rate $3,304

Shelter Island Men & Women Car Insurance

2624 Shelter Island Adults (100% of total population), 45% Men & 55% Women.

Shelter Island Sagaponack Cutchogue Springs New York
All Women $1720 +$9 -$19 +$28 -$447
Married Women $1665 +$9 -$18 +$27 -$433
All Men $2571 +$14 -$28 +$42 -$669
Married Men $2479 +$13 -$27 +$40 -$645

The typical insurance rate of $2571 that Shelter Island Men pay varies from Sagaponack (+$14), Cutchogue (-$28), Springs (+$42) and New York (-$669). In Shelter Island, married men pay $814 more than married women.

Example

  • 2011 Lincoln MKS Base Married Men Insurance Rate $2,381
  • 2013 Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD CC Work Truck Married Women Insurance Rate $2,391

Shelter Island Senior Car Insurance

1047 Shelter Island Seniors (39% of total population), 45% Senior Men & 55% Senior Women.

Shelter Island Orient North Sea East Hampton North New York
All Seniors $2090 -$45 -$45 +$34 -$544
Senior Men $2220 -$48 -$48 +$36 -$578
Senior Women $1924 -$42 -$42 +$31 -$501

Shelter Island seniors pay $2090 in insurance compared to Orient (-$45), North Sea (-$45), East Hampton North (+$34) and New York (-$544). In Shelter Island, senior men pay $296 more than senior women.

Shelter Island Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Shelter Island Population with 1 Vehicle 494 (45% of Shelter Island population), 2 Vehicles 427 (39% of the Shelter Island population) and 3 vehicles 129 (12% of the population)

Shelter Island Amagansett Springs East Hampton North New York
2 Vehicles $3515 +$19 +$57 +$57 -$913
3 Vehicles $5365 +$29 +$87 +$87 -$1394
4 Vehicles $7215 +$39 +$117 +$117 -$1875

Shelter Island Insurance Rates by Make

Shelter Island Acura Insurance

Acura RDX models such as RDX & Tech cost about $1636 to $1709 in Shelter Island compared to Acura ZDX (-$370) Acura TSX (-$250) & Acura TL (-$390).

Acura MDX insurance rate is $1667 in Shelter Island. Insurance for a 2011 Acura MDX 5 Door 4WD Utility in Shelter Island is $1640 & differs from nearby locations such as Suffolk County (-$550), Riverhead (-$430), Clinton, CT (+$380), Aquebogue (+$530) and Gales Ferry, CT (+$730).

Shelter Island Audi Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Audi Q7 models such as 3.0 Quattro, S-line Prestige, Premium & TDI Prestige are around $2137 to $2381 compared to Audi A7 (+$30) Audi A4 (+$340) & Audi TT (+$100).

Audi A8 L Quattro insurance rate is $2772 in Shelter Island. A 2011 Audi A8 L Quattro 4 Door Sedan AWD's insurance costs in Shelter Island is $2730 while nearby places such as Waterford, CT, Lyme, CT, Poquonock Bridge, CT, Watch Hill, RI and County subdivisions not defined, CT are costlier by $780, $1800, $1940, $1940 and $2020 respectively

ModelsInsurance RateQuogueRemsenburg-SpeonkEast Hampton NorthHampton Bays
Q5$1960-$590-$630-$730-$760
TTS$2350-$710-$760-$880-$910
S5$2420-$730-$780-$900-$940
S4$2330-$700-$750-$870-$900
A3$1900-$570-$610-$710-$740
A5$2070-$620-$670-$770-$800
A6$2300-$690-$740-$860-$890

Shelter Island BMW Insurance

Shelter Island rates for BMW Z series models such as 28i sDRIVE, 35i sDRIVE & 35is sDRIVE are roughly $1958 to $2327 compared to BMW 5 series (+$70) BMW 7 series (-$610) & BMW 6 series (-$1670).

Shelter Island rates for BMW 3 series models such as 328i, 335i & 335is are about $1987 to $2367. Insurance for a 2013 BMW 335is 2 Door Coupe in Shelter Island is $2330 and differs from nearby places such as Quiogue (-$880), Guilford, CT (-$560), Noank, CT (-$460), Poospatuck (+$630) and Southold (+$780).

ModelsInsurance RateManorvilleWest Hampton DunesOxoboxo River, CTSaybrook Manor, CT
X series$2110-$680-$790-$1250-$1340
1 series$1970-$630-$740-$1170-$1250
M series$2840-$910-$1060-$1680-$1810

Shelter Island Buick Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateKillingworth, CTColchester, CTEast HamptonOrient
Lacrosse$1700+$380-$500-$550-$550
Enclave$1710+$390-$500-$550-$550
Regal$1670+$380-$490-$540-$540

Shelter Island Cadillac Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateGroton, CTWesthamptonEast QuogueConning Towers Nautilus Park, CT
Escalade$2220+$240-$670-$680-$990
SRX$1860+$200-$560-$570-$830
CTS$1970+$210-$590-$610-$880

Shelter Island Chevrolet Insurance

Chevrolet Cruze models such as Eco, LS, LTZ & LT cost around $1721 to $1732 in Shelter Island compared to Chevrolet Avalanche (-$80) Chevrolet Express (+$110) & Chevrolet Equinox (+$100).

Shelter Island rates for Chevrolet Silverado models such as 1500 Work Truck, 1500 LT & 1500 LTZ are roughly $1637 to $1802. The rates for a car such as 2011 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT 4WD 4 Door Crew Cab 144WB Ethanol would be about $1660 which is about 5% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateMystic, CTChester, CTWainscottEast Hampton
Corvette$2210+$530-$500-$680-$710
Malibu$1740+$420-$400-$540-$560
Camaro$1870+$450-$420-$580-$600

Shelter Island Chrysler Insurance

Chrysler Town models such as & Country Limited, & Country Touring & & Country Touring L cost roughly $1610 to $1551 in Shelter Island compared to Chrysler 200 (-$190) Chrysler 300C (-$270) & Chrysler 300 (-$220).

Shelter Island Dodge Insurance

Dodge Challenger models such as SRT8, SXT & R/T cost around $2141 to $1877 in Shelter Island compared to Dodge Charger (-$80) Dodge Journey (+$260) & Dodge Durango (+$100).

Dodge Grand Caravan SXT insurance rate is $1535 in Shelter Island. A 2010 Dodge Grand Caravan SXT 2WD 4 Door Van's insurance costs in Shelter Island is $1510 while nearby places such as Clinton, CT, Pawcatuck, CT, Mattituck and Napeague are costlier by $350, $400, $540 and $570 respectively whereas Quiogue is cheaper by $570.

Shelter Island rates for Dodge Avenger models such as SE, R/T & SXT are approximately $1772 to $1781. The rates for a car such as 2010 Dodge Avenger SE 4 Door Sedan would be about $1740 which is about 5% of the total cost of a car.

Shelter Island Ford Insurance

Ford Fiesta models such as S & SE cost around $1643 to $1644 in Shelter Island compared to Ford Expedition (-$170) Ford Taurus (-$140) & Ford Transit (+$60).

Shelter Island rates for Ford Mustang models such as Mustang, GT, Shelby GT500 & Boss 302 are about $1812 to $2277. Insurance for a 2008 Ford Mustang Boss 302 2 Door Coupe in Shelter Island is $2240 and is in contrast with close by places such as East Lyme, CT (+$180), Niantic, CT (+$510), Moodus, CT (+$840), Springs (+$840) and Guilford Center, CT (+$1540).

ModelsInsurance RateEast MorichesNoank, CTHaddam, CTNapeague
Flex$1760+$640+$350-$130-$670
Explorer$1710+$620+$340-$130-$650
F-150$1660+$610+$330-$120-$630
Focus$1740+$630+$340-$130-$660
Fusion$1720+$630+$340-$130-$650
Edge$1690+$620+$330-$120-$640

Shelter Island GMC Insurance

GMC Terrain models such as SLE1 AWD & SLE1 cost approximately $1606 to $1560 in Shelter Island compared to GMC Acadia (-$90) GMC Yukon (-$180) & GMC Sierra (-$260).

Shelter Island Honda Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Honda CR-V models such as EX & EX-L are around $1510 to $1581 compared to Honda Odyssey (-$0) Honda Pilot (-$120) & Honda Civic (-$290).

Shelter Island rates for Honda Fit models such as Fit & Sport are roughly $1631 to $1651. The rates for a car such as 2012 Honda Fit Sport 4 Door Hatchback would be about $1630 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateNorth SeaNew London County, CTNapeagueEssex, CT
Accord$1740-$560-$650-$660-$1260
CR-Z$1820-$590-$680-$690-$1320
Insight$1790-$580-$670-$680-$1300

Shelter Island Hyundai Insurance

Hyundai Sonata models such as Limited, GLS & SE cost about $1793 to $1731 in Shelter Island compared to Hyundai Genesis (-$210) Hyundai Veloster (+$40) & Hyundai Accent (-$0).

ModelsInsurance RateRemsenburg-SpeonkDeep River Center, CTConning Towers Nautilus Park, CTWatch Hill, RI
Elantra$1800-$580-$720-$800-$1280
Tucson$1590-$510-$640-$710-$1130
Equus$2280-$730-$920-$1020-$1620

Shelter Island Jeep Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateSouthamptonNiantic, CTMashantucket, CTOrient
Patriot$1580-$180-$360-$390-$510
Grand$1660-$190-$380-$410-$530
Compass$1610-$190-$370-$400-$520

Shelter Island Kia Insurance

Kia Sportage models such as LX, SX, EX & Sportage cost about $1594 to $1535 in Shelter Island compared to Kia Sorento (-$10) Kia Sedona (+$10) & Kia Soul (-$40).

ModelsInsurance RateShirleyEast Lyme, CTChester, CTClinton, CT
Optima$1820-$80-$150-$410-$430
Rio$1800-$80-$150-$410-$420
Forte$1770-$80-$140-$400-$420

Shelter Island Lexus Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Lexus GX 460 is $1964 compared to Lexus ES (+$80) Lexus IS (-$120) & Lexus GX460 (-$0).

Lexus RX models such as 350 & 450h cost about $1863 to $1939 in Shelter Island. Insurance for a 2011 Lexus RX 450h 4 Door Utility Hybrid in Shelter Island is $1910 in contrast with nearby locations such as Westerly, RI (+$180), Niantic, CT (+$430), Wainscott (+$590), Conning Towers Nautilus Park, CT (+$850) and Essex Village, CT (+$1380).

Shelter Island rates for Lexus LS models such as 460 & 460 L are approximately $2462 to $2610. A 2011 Lexus LS 460 4 Door Sedan AWD's insurance costs in Shelter Island is $2420 while nearby places such as Chester, CT, Mashantucket, CT, New London County, CT and Saybrook Manor, CT are costlier by $550, $600, $900 and $1540 respectively whereas Rocky Point is cheaper by $180.

Shelter Island Lincoln Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Lincoln MKS is $1971 compared to Lincoln MKZ (+$200) Lincoln MKX (+$300) & Lincoln MKT (+$190).

Shelter Island rates for Lincoln Navigator models such as Navigator & L are around $2010 to $2095. A 2013 Lincoln Navigator L 4 Door 2WD SUV Ethanol's insurance costs in Shelter Island is $2060 and differs from nearby locations such as Guilford, CT (-$500), Chester Center, CT (+$300), Calverton (+$330), West Hampton Dunes (+$770) and Deep River Center, CT (+$830).

Shelter Island Mazda Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Mazda CX-9 models such as Grand Touring, Sport & Touring are roughly $1687 to $1648 compared to Mazda Mazdaspeed3 (-$240) Mazda Mazda5 (-$40) & Mazda Mazda6s (-$190).

Shelter Island rates for Mazda Mazda6i models such as Touring, Touring Plus & Mazda6i are nearly $1659 to $1736. Insurance for a 2009 Mazda Mazda6i Touring 4 Door Sedan in Shelter Island is $1630 while nearby places such as Salem, CT, Pawcatuck, CT, Ledyard, CT, Hampton Bays and Fenwick, CT are costlier by $220, $430, $610, $630 and $1070 respectively

Mazda MX5 models such as Miata Sport & Miata Grand Touring cost nearly $1504 to $1624 in Shelter Island. A 2010 Mazda MX5 Miata Sport 2WD 2 Door Convertible's insurance costs in Shelter Island is $1480 in contrast with close by regions such as Mystic, CT (-$360), Noank, CT (-$290), East Quogue (+$460), Bridgehampton (+$530) and Sagaponack (+$530).

ModelsInsurance RateWest Hampton DunesSpringsEssex, CTGroton Long Point, CT
Mazda3i$1790-$670-$670-$1300-$1300
Mazda2$1650-$620-$620-$1190-$1190
Mazda3s$1850-$690-$690-$1340-$1340

Shelter Island Nissan Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Nissan Pathfinder models such as SV & S are about $1636 to $1510 compared to Nissan Versa (-$60) Nissan Rogue (-$80) & Nissan 370Z (-$360).

Nissan Juke models such as SL, S & SV cost approximately $1709 to $1720 in Shelter Island. Insurance for a 2009 Nissan Juke SL 4 Door Hatchback in Shelter Island is $1680 while nearby places such as Montauk, Mattituck and North Haven are costlier by $550, $600 and $640 respectively whereas Killingworth, CT and Rocky Point are cheaper by $380 and $120 respectively.

ModelsInsurance RateQuiogueNew London, CTStonington, CTChester, CT
NV3500$1750+$660+$180+$60-$400
Altima$1970+$750+$210+$70-$450
Titan$1780+$670+$190+$60-$400
Murano$1650+$630+$170+$60-$370
Quest$1730+$660+$180+$60-$390
Armada$1920+$730+$200+$70-$440
Sentra$1890+$720+$200+$70-$430
Maxima$1990+$750+$210+$70-$450

Shelter Island Toyota Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Toyota Prius models such as v, Plug-In hybrid, Prius & c are around $1656 to $1640 compared to Toyota 4Runner (-$40) Toyota Camry (-$80) & Toyota Sequoia (-$70).

Toyota Corolla models such as L, LE & S cost approximately $1721 to $1732 in Shelter Island. A 2011 Toyota Corolla S 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Shelter Island is $1710 while nearby places such as Shirley, Haddam, CT, Mattituck and Eastport are costlier by $80, $130, $610 and $640 respectively whereas Flanders is cheaper by $250.

Toyota Sienna insurance rate is $1518 in Shelter Island. A 2011 Toyota Sienna 5 Door Wagon's insurance costs in Shelter Island is $1500 and differs from close by regions such as Dering Harbor (+$540), Bridgehampton (+$540), Poquonock Bridge, CT (+$1060), Old Saybrook Center, CT (+$1090) and Madison, CT (+$1120).

Toyota Avalon Limited insurance rate is $1706 in Shelter Island. The rates for a car such as 2011 Toyota Avalon Limited 4 Door Sedan would be about $1680 which is about 4% of the total cost of a car.

Shelter Island Volkswagen Insurance

Shelter Island rates for Volkswagen Eos 2.0T is $1918 compared to Volkswagen Golf (+$180) Volkswagen CC (+$90) & Volkswagen Touareg (-$110).

Volkswagen GTI models such as Autobahn & GTI cost roughly $1750 to $1825 in Shelter Island. The rates for a car such as 2009 Volkswagen GTI 2 Door Coupe 2.0T would be about $1800 which is about 2% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateMystic, CTNoank, CTWesthamptonCounty subdivisions not defined, CT
Tiguan$1830+$440+$360-$550-$1350
Jetta$1670+$400+$330-$500-$1230
Passat$1720+$410+$340-$520-$1270


We also offer auto insurance in these cities NY:

  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shelter Island Heights (Suffolk County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shenorock (Westchester County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Sherburne (Chenango County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Sheridan (Chautauqua County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Sherman (Chautauqua County), NY