Enter ZIP Code

Cheap Auto Insurance U.S.Cheap Car Insurance New York → Shelter Island Heights (Suffolk County)

Looking for cheap car insurance in Shelter Island Heights (NY)? You have come to the right place!

On our website you will see quotes and rates offered by insurance companies, as well as be able to choose and send an application online.

We know how good it is to be safe in a car while driving but various situations may happen sometimes. That's why it's better to insure your car first after buying.

What do you need to do for this? Enter your ZIP code, choose an insurance company or agency, and send your request.

Soon you'll get a reply from the company representative. We wish you a safe driving and a good mood!

We offer car insurance in Shelter Island Heights (Suffolk County), NY:



Car Insurance Agents within 50 miles of Shelter Island Heights, NY

DOLAN DERMOT

Bridgehampton, NY - 11932 - 1193  near Enclave Inn Bridgehampton

Call: (631) 537-0223
Get a Quote

STATE FARM INSURANCE

2228 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY - 11932 - 1193  near Butter Ln,montauk Hwy

Call: (631) 537-2622
Get a Quote

Allstate Insurance

1983 Montauk Hwy , Brookhaven, NY - 11719   near Chapel Rd,country Rd

Call: (631) 286-7969
Get a Quote

Kevin J McCarthy Agency Incorporated

2470 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY - 11719 - 1172  near Country Rd,montauk Hwy

Call: (631) 286-6000
Get a Quote

Apfco Inc

1700 Montauk Hwy, Bellport, NY - 11713 - 1900 near Montauk Hwy,post Ave

Call: (631) 286-1800
Get a Quote

Chase Bank

32 Station Rd, Bellport, NY - 11713 - 1171  near Kreamer St,station Rd

Call: (631) 286-4200
Get a Quote

JOSEPH MONCELLO

61 Montauk Highway , Blue Point, NY - 11715   near Blue Point Ave,montauk Hwy

Call: (631) 363-8100
Get a Quote

Chase Bank

925 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY - 11705 - 1170  near Montauk Hwy,sylvan Ave

Call: (631) 472-2201
Get a Quote

State Farm Insurance

972 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY - 11705 - 1170 near Gillette Ave,montauk Hwy

Call: (631) 363-2468
Get a Quote

Ameriprise Financial

640 Johnson Ave, Bohemia, NY - 11716 - 1172 near Corporate Dr,johnson Ave

Call: (631) 582-9770
Get a Quote

Chase Bank

4170 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Bohemia, NY - 11716 - 1172  near Corporate Dr,state Highway 454

Call: (631) 467-6070
Get a Quote


Shelter Island Heights, NY Auto Insurance Rates

Shelter Island Heights, NY residents can save $760 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Shelter Island Heights car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

LowestAverageHighest
$1,200 $1,900 $10,220

Shelter Island Heights Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Shelter Island Heights, NY's average car insurance of $1900 differs from Bridgehampton, NY (-$40), Water Mill, NY (-$90), Peconic, NY (-$50) and New York (-$531)

Shelter Island Heights Bridgehampton, NY Water Mill, NY Peconic, NY New York
Median Insurance Rates $1900 -$40 -$90 -$50 -$531

Shelter Island Heights Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Shelter Island Heights Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Shelter Island Heights Shelter Island Heights Driver Demographics Shelter Island Heights Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Shelter Island Heights Insurance Savings
Other Area
Merkel Ln2006 Chrysler Town and Country Touring48 year married woman$1,565$554
Coecles Pl2006 Toyota Camry LE34 year woman$1,581$934
Willow Pond Rd2012 Mazda MAZDA6 i Touring19 year teenager$3,559$397
Hillside Dr2004 Acura MDX Touring w/Navi64 year male senior$2,310$785
Heron Ln2004 Nissan 350Z Touring19 year female teenager$3,480$350
Worthy Way2014 Honda Civic LX19 year male teenager$3,622$338
Carousel Ln2014 Dodge Grand Caravan SE37 year man$2,538$871
Waverly Pl2014 Kia Optima LX69 year female senior$1,796$758
Johnston Rd2012 Buick Lacrosse Premium40 year married man$2,311$576
Pennys Path2013 Ford Fusion SE74 year senior$2,006$781

Shelter Island Heights Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Shelter Island Heights Shelter Island East Marion Bridgehampton New York
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $3534 -$93 -$205 -$75 -$988
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $7456 -$197 -$433 -$158 -$2085
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $6926 -$182 -$402 -$147 -$1936

The Post DUI insurance in Shelter Island Heights, NY's is $3534 compared to Shelter Island (-$93), East Marion (-$205), Bridgehampton (-$75) and New York (-$988)

In Shelter Island Heights, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $530 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2012 Mazda MAZDA6 i Touring in Shelter Island Heights, NY would pay $6846 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $6361.

Shelter Island Heights Car Insurance by Segment

Shelter Island Heights Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

160 Shelter Island Heights Teenagers (11% of total population), 38% Male & 63% Female.

Shelter Island Heights East Hampton North East Marion Sag Harbor New York
All Teenagers $3876 -$41 -$225 -$102 -$1084
Male Teenager $4009 -$43 -$233 -$106 -$1121
Female Teenager $3724 -$40 -$216 -$98 -$1041

Shelter Island Heights teenagers pay $3876 in insurance in contrast with East Hampton North (-$41), East Marion (-$225), Sag Harbor (-$102) and New York (-$1084). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Shelter Island Heights is $285

Example

  • 2014 Hyundai Tucson Limited Male Teenager Insurance Rate $3,852
  • 2011 Lincoln MKS Base Female Teenager Insurance Rate $3,823

Shelter Island Heights Men & Women Car Insurance

1353 Shelter Island Heights Adults (100% of total population), 45% Men & 55% Women.

Shelter Island Heights East Hampton North Wainscott Bridgehampton New York
All Women $1767 -$19 -$103 -$38 -$494
Married Women $1710 -$18 -$99 -$36 -$478
All Men $2641 -$28 -$153 -$56 -$739
Married Men $2546 -$27 -$148 -$54 -$712

The typical insurance rate of $2641 that Shelter Island Heights Men pay varies from East Hampton North (-$28), Wainscott (-$153), Bridgehampton (-$56) and New York (-$739). In Shelter Island Heights, married men pay $836 more than married women.

Example

  • 2014 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Sport Married Men Insurance Rate $2,458
  • 2013 Volkswagen Tiguan S Married Women Insurance Rate $2,405

Shelter Island Heights Senior Car Insurance

497 Shelter Island Heights Seniors (36% of total population), 43% Senior Men & 57% Senior Women.

Shelter Island Heights Dering Harbor Northwest Harbor North Sea New York
All Seniors $2147 -$46 -$46 -$102 -$601
Senior Men $2280 -$48 -$48 -$108 -$638
Senior Women $1976 -$42 -$42 -$94 -$553

Shelter Island Heights seniors pay $2147 in insurance compared to Dering Harbor (-$46), Northwest Harbor (-$46), North Sea (-$102) and New York (-$601). In Shelter Island Heights, senior men pay $304 more than senior women.

Shelter Island Heights Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Shelter Island Heights Population with 1 Vehicle 231 (42% of Shelter Island Heights population), 2 Vehicles 216 (39% of the Shelter Island Heights population) and 3 vehicles 66 (12% of the population)

Shelter Island Heights Dering Harbor Water Mill Springs New York
2 Vehicles $3610 -$76 -$171 -$38 -$1008
3 Vehicles $5510 -$116 -$261 -$58 -$1539
4 Vehicles $7410 -$156 -$351 -$78 -$2070

Shelter Island Heights Insurance Rates by Make

Shelter Island Heights Acura Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Acura TL models such as SH, Tech, TL, Advance, SH Tech & SH Advance are around $2156 to $2169 compared to Acura TSX (+$140) Acura RDX (+$390) & Acura MDX (+$400).

Acura ZDX insurance rate is $2131 in Shelter Island Heights. The rates for a car such as 2011 Acura ZDX 2 Door 4WD would be about $2100 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Shelter Island Heights Audi Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Audi TT 2.0T Quattro is $2295 compared to Audi A3 (+$350) Audi Q7 (-$100) & Audi A8 (-$550).

ModelsInsurance RateRiverheadSalem, CTAmagansettGuilford Center, CT
Q5$2020+$530-$270-$720-$1390
TTS$2410+$630-$320-$860-$1660
S5$2480+$650-$330-$890-$1700
S4$2400+$630-$320-$860-$1650
A5$2120+$560-$280-$760-$1460
A4$2060+$540-$270-$740-$1420
A7$2370+$620-$310-$850-$1630
A6$2360+$620-$310-$850-$1620

Shelter Island Heights BMW Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for BMW 3 series models such as 335i, 335is & 328i are nearly $2285 to $2041 compared to BMW 1 series (+$330) BMW Z series (-$40) & BMW 5 series (+$30).

BMW X series models such as xDrive 28i, xDrive 35i, 35I, 35D, XDrive 35i, 5.0i & XDrive 50i cost nearly $1762 to $2309 in Shelter Island Heights. A 2008 BMW X5 5.0i 4WD 4 Door's insurance costs in Shelter Island Heights is $2190 and differs from nearby locations such as Center Moriches (-$800), East Moriches (-$800), Killingworth, CT (-$490), Haddam, CT (+$160) and North Sea (+$710).

ModelsInsurance RateNoank, CTWainscottWater MillRiverside
7 series$3020+$590-$930-$970-$1020
6 series$4110+$810-$1260-$1320-$1380
M series$2920+$570-$900-$940-$980

Shelter Island Heights Buick Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateBranford Center, CTFishers IslandOld Mystic, CTCounty subdivisions not defined, CT
Lacrosse$1750-$320-$650-$820-$1290
Enclave$1750-$320-$650-$820-$1290
Regal$1720-$320-$640-$810-$1270

Shelter Island Heights Cadillac Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateAmagansettMattituckLedyard, CTSprings
Escalade$2280-$820-$820-$850-$850
SRX$1920-$690-$690-$720-$720
CTS$2020-$720-$720-$750-$750

Shelter Island Heights Chevrolet Insurance

Chevrolet Camaro models such as LS, LT & SS cost roughly $1804 to $2026 in Shelter Island Heights compared to Chevrolet Corvette (-$350) Chevrolet Equinox (+$250) & Chevrolet Cruze (+$140).

Shelter Island Heights rates for Chevrolet Malibu models such as LS, LT & LTZ are about $1682 to $1848. Insurance for a 2008 Chevrolet Malibu LT 4 Door Sedan in Shelter Island Heights is $1750 while nearby places such as Haddam, CT, Greenport West, Noyack, Madison Center, CT and Essex, CT are costlier by $130, $540, $610, $1110 and $1270 respectively

ModelsInsurance RatePeconicSagaponackMontville, CTMisquamicut, RI
Express$1660-$580-$600-$830-$1180
Avalanche$1860-$650-$670-$930-$1320
Silverado$1730-$610-$620-$860-$1230

Shelter Island Heights Chrysler Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Chrysler Town models such as & Country Limited, & Country Touring & & Country Touring L are approximately $1654 to $1593 compared to Chrysler 300C (-$280) Chrysler 300 (-$230) & Chrysler 200 (-$200).

Shelter Island Heights Dodge Insurance

Dodge Journey models such as SXT & Crew cost nearly $1633 to $1665 in Shelter Island Heights compared to Dodge Avenger (-$150) Dodge Challenger (-$260) & Dodge Durango (-$150).

Shelter Island Heights rates for Dodge Charger models such as SXT, SE, R/T & SRT8 are nearly $1920 to $2430. The rates for a car such as 2008 Dodge Charger SE 4 Door Sedan would be about $1900 which is about 3% of the total cost of a car.

Dodge Grand Caravan SXT insurance rate is $1576 in Shelter Island Heights. Insurance for a 2008 Dodge Grand Caravan SXT 2WD 4 Door Van in Shelter Island Heights is $1550 while nearby places such as Clinton, CT, East Quogue, Orient, Old Lyme, CT and Watch Hill, RI are costlier by $360, $480, $500, $1010 and $1100 respectively

Shelter Island Heights Ford Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Ford Fiesta models such as S & SE are nearly $1687 to $1689 compared to Ford F-150 (-$10) Ford Transit (+$70) & Ford Focus (-$100).

Ford Mustang models such as Mustang, GT, Shelby GT500 & Boss 302 cost around $1861 to $2338 in Shelter Island Heights. The rates for a car such as 2010 Ford Mustang Shelby GT500 2 Door Convertible would be about $2300 which is about 7% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateSalem, CTRemsenburg-SpeonkNorth HavenMadison, CT
Flex$1800-$240-$580-$690-$1340
Explorer$1750-$230-$560-$670-$1310
Expedition$1860-$250-$600-$710-$1390
Taurus$1830-$240-$590-$700-$1360
Fusion$1760-$230-$570-$670-$1310
Edge$1730-$230-$560-$660-$1290

Shelter Island Heights GMC Insurance

ModelsInsurance RateSuffolk CountyNoyackWatch Hill, RIEssex, CT
Sierra$1880+$630-$660-$1330-$1360
Acadia$1700+$570-$600-$1210-$1230
Terrain$1620+$540-$570-$1150-$1170
Yukon$1800+$600-$630-$1280-$1300

Shelter Island Heights Honda Insurance

Honda Odyssey models such as LX, Touring Elite, Touring, EX-L & EX cost nearly $1468 to $1609 in Shelter Island Heights compared to Honda Pilot (-$120) Honda Accord (-$160) & Honda CR-Z (-$250).

Honda Fit models such as Fit & Sport cost nearly $1675 to $1695 in Shelter Island Heights. The rates for a car such as 2008 Honda Fit Sport 4 Door Hatchback would be about $1670 which is about 10% of the total cost of a car.

ModelsInsurance RateKillingworth, CTNorth Branford, CTRemsenburg-SpeonkDeep River Center, CT
CR-V$1620+$370-$250-$520-$650
Civic$1920+$430-$300-$620-$770
Insight$1840+$420-$280-$590-$740

Shelter Island Heights Hyundai Insurance

Hyundai Accent models such as GLS, GS & SE cost approximately $1823 to $1808 in Shelter Island Heights compared to Hyundai Veloster (+$50) Hyundai Elantra (-$30) & Hyundai Tucson (+$180).

ModelsInsurance RateHigganum, CTCutchogueFishers IslandCounty subdivisions not defined, CT
Sonata$1810-$600-$610-$680-$1340
Genesis$2030-$670-$680-$760-$1500
Equus$2350-$770-$790-$880-$1740

Shelter Island Heights Jeep Insurance

Jeep Patriot models such as Sport & Limited cost about $1503 to $1622 in Shelter Island Heights. A 2008 Jeep Patriot Sport 2WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Shelter Island Heights is $1480 is different from close by places such as Shirley (+$70), Clinton, CT (+$350), Remsenburg-Speonk (+$480), East Shoreham (+$500) and Conning Towers Nautilus Park, CT (+$660).

Shelter Island Heights rates for Jeep Grand models such as Cherokee Limited, Cherokee Laredo & Cherokee Overland are around $1690 to $1719. A 2012 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2WD 4 Door Utility's insurance costs in Shelter Island Heights is $1680 while nearby places such as Salem, CT and Conning Towers Nautilus Park, CT are costlier by $220 and $750 respectively whereas Riverhead, Guilford, CT and Yaphank are cheaper by $440, $400 and $180 respectively.

Shelter Island Heights rates for Jeep Compass models such as Sport & Limited are around $1601 to $1648. The rates for a car such as 2008 Jeep Compass Sport 2WD 4 Door Utility would be about $1570 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Shelter Island Heights Kia Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Kia Forte models such as LX, Koup EX, EX, SX & Koup SX are roughly $1851 to $1865 compared to Kia Sorento (+$120) Kia Sedona (+$140) & Kia Sportage (+$130).

ModelsInsurance RateNiantic, CTWainscottEast QuogueJamesport
Optima$1870-$420-$580-$580-$670
Rio$1840-$420-$570-$570-$660
Soul$1730-$390-$530-$530-$620

Shelter Island Heights Lexus Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Lexus RX models such as 350 & 450h are roughly $1913 to $1991 compared to Lexus ES (+$60) Lexus GX460 (-$30) & Lexus GX (-$30).

Shelter Island Heights rates for Lexus IS models such as 250, 250C, 350, 350C, 350 AWD & F are nearly $1962 to $3218. The rates for a car such as 2012 Lexus IS 250C 2 Door Convertible would be about $2100 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Shelter Island Heights rates for Lexus LS models such as 460 & 460 L are about $2528 to $2681. A 2010 Lexus LS 460 4 Door Sedan AWD's insurance costs in Shelter Island Heights is $2490 while nearby places such as Shoreham, Westhampton Beach, Old Mystic, CT and Old Saybrook Center, CT are costlier by $800, $870, $1170 and $1800 respectively whereas New London, CT is cheaper by $260.

Shelter Island Heights Lincoln Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Lincoln MKX is $1807 compared to Lincoln MKZ (-$100) Lincoln Navigator (-$300) & Lincoln MKT (-$110).

Lincoln MKS insurance rate is $2024 in Shelter Island Heights. Insurance for a 2010 Lincoln MKS 4 Door Sedan in Shelter Island Heights is $1990 while nearby places such as East Marion, East Shoreham and Gales Ferry, CT are costlier by $610, $670 and $890 respectively whereas Guilford, CT and Groton, CT are cheaper by $480 and $210 respectively.

Shelter Island Heights Mazda Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Mazda Mazda6s models such as Touring Plus & Mazda6s are about $1826 to $1902 compared to Mazda MX5 (+$230) Mazda Mazda3s (-$0) & Mazda Mazdaspeed3 (-$50).

Mazda Mazda6i models such as Touring, Touring Plus & Mazda6i cost roughly $1704 to $1783 in Shelter Island Heights. A 2008 Mazda Mazda6i Touring 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Shelter Island Heights is $1680 is different from nearby places such as Groton, CT (-$180), Mastic (+$100), North Haven, CT (+$250), Greenport West (+$520) and Springs (+$630).

ModelsInsurance RateCutchogueMattituckSaybrook Manor, CTOld Saybrook Center, CT
CX-9$1700-$570-$610-$1080-$1230
Mazda3i$1840-$620-$660-$1170-$1330
Mazda2$1700-$570-$610-$1080-$1230
Mazda5$1750-$590-$630-$1110-$1270

Shelter Island Heights Nissan Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Nissan Rogue S is $1745 compared to Nissan NV3500 (-$40) Nissan Pathfinder (+$80) & Nissan Versa (+$30).

ModelsInsurance RateMystic, CTCalvertonEast MarionGreenport West
Altima$2020+$490-$330-$620-$620
Titan$1830+$440-$300-$560-$560
370Z$2030+$490-$330-$620-$620
Murano$1700+$410-$270-$520-$520
Quest$1780+$430-$290-$550-$550
Armada$1970+$470-$320-$610-$610
Juke$1760+$420-$280-$540-$540
Sentra$1940+$470-$310-$600-$600
Maxima$2040+$490-$330-$630-$630

Shelter Island Heights Toyota Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Toyota Sequoia models such as Platinum, SR5 & Limited are about $1773 to $1765 compared to Toyota Camry (-$10) Toyota 4Runner (+$30) & Toyota Sienna (+$210).

Shelter Island Heights rates for Toyota Prius models such as c, v, Prius & Plug-In hybrid are roughly $1684 to $1790. The rates for a car such as 2008 Toyota Prius 4 Door Hatchback Hybrid would be about $1670 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Toyota Corolla models such as L, LE & S cost nearly $1768 to $1779 in Shelter Island Heights. Insurance for a 2011 Toyota Corolla S 4 Door Sedan in Shelter Island Heights is $1750 while nearby places such as Salem, CT, Dering Harbor, New Suffolk and Conning Towers Nautilus Park, CT are costlier by $230, $630, $650 and $780 respectively whereas East Moriches is cheaper by $640.

Toyota Avalon Limited insurance rate is $1752 in Shelter Island Heights. Insurance for a 2009 Toyota Avalon Limited 4 Door Sedan in Shelter Island Heights is $1720 & differs from close by regions such as Guilford, CT (-$410), Clinton, CT (+$400), East Marion (+$530), Remsenburg-Speonk (+$550) and Old Lyme, CT (+$1120).

Shelter Island Heights Volkswagen Insurance

Shelter Island Heights rates for Volkswagen Touareg models such as TDI, Hybrid & Touareg are about $2088 to $1854 compared to Volkswagen Tiguan (+$210) Volkswagen Passat (+$330) & Volkswagen GTI (+$290).

Volkswagen Golf models such as Golf & TDI cost about $1644 to $1822 in Shelter Island Heights. Insurance for a 2012 Volkswagen Golf TDI 2 Door Hatchback in Shelter Island Heights is $1800 and is in contrast with places such as Deep River, CT (+$500), North Sea (+$580), East Shoreham (+$610), Shelter Island (+$630) and Sagaponack (+$650).

ModelsInsurance RateMystic, CTCalvertonAquebogueEast Hampton North
CC$1880+$450-$300-$610-$700
Eos$1970+$470-$320-$630-$740
Jetta$1720+$410-$280-$550-$640


We also offer auto insurance in these cities NY:

  • Cheap Car Insurance in Sharon Springs (Schoharie County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shelter Island (Suffolk County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shenorock (Westchester County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Sherburne (Chenango County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Sheridan (Chautauqua County), NY