Enter ZIP Code

Cheap Auto Insurance U.S.Cheap Car Insurance New York → Shirley (Suffolk County)

Looking for cheap car insurance in Shirley (NY)? You have come to the right place!

On our website you will see quotes and rates offered by insurance companies, as well as be able to choose and send an application online.

We know how good it is to be safe in a car while driving but various situations may happen sometimes. That's why it's better to insure your car first after buying.

What do you need to do for this? Enter your ZIP code, choose an insurance company or agency, and send your request.

Soon you'll get a reply from the company representative. We wish you a safe driving and a good mood!

We offer car insurance in Shirley (Suffolk County), NY:



Car Insurance Agents in Shirley, NY

Chase Bank

425 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley, NY - 11967 - 1197  near Lama Dr,margin Dr

Call: (631) 399-3101
more addresses or Get a Quote

Farmers Insurance Group

412 Wellwood Dr, Shirley, NY - 11967 - 1328  near Moriches Middle Island Rd,wellwood Dr

Call: (631) 924-4787
Get a Quote

Lighthouse Insurance Agency

960B Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY - 11967 - 2119 near Montauk Hwy,versa Pl

Call: (631) 399-0300
Get a Quote

Michelle De Santis - Allstate Insurance Agent

895 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY - 11967 - 1197 near Montauk Hwy,ormond Pl

Call: (631) 399-1100
Get a Quote


Shirley, NY Auto Insurance Rates

Shirley, NY residents can save $570 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Shirley car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

LowestAverageHighest
$900 $1,430 $7,690

Shirley Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Shirley, NY's average car insurance of $1430 differs from West Hampton Dunes, NY (+$450), Center Moriches, NY (-$560), Mastic, NY (+$20) and New York (-$61)

Shirley West Hampton Dunes, NY Center Moriches, NY Mastic, NY New York
Median Insurance Rates $1430 +$450 -$560 +$20 -$61

Shirley Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Shirley Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Shirley Shirley Driver Demographics Shirley Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Shirley Insurance Savings
Old Mastic
Palmetto Dr2006 Chrysler Town and Country Touring19 year male teenager$2,755$815
Fairlawn Ct2004 Acura MDX Touring w/Navi16 year teenager$2,962$588
Smith-Point2006 Toyota Camry Standard49 year married man$1,723$879
South Haven
Wellwood Dr2006 Lexus ES 330 Base63 year senior$1,853$964
Sorrel Dr2012 Mazda MAZDA6 i Touring45 year woman$1,220$321
Kent Dr2004 Nissan 350Z Enthusiast26 year married woman$1,200$600
South Manor
Moran Ct2014 Dodge Grand Caravan SE70 year female senior$1,438$403
Silas Carter Rd2014 Honda Civic LX37 year man$1,798$482
Upton
Wellwood Dr2014 Kia Optima LX77 year male senior$1,564$604
Crestwood Dr2008 GMC Sierra 1500 SLT16 year female teenager$2,642$306

Shirley Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Shirley East Moriches Eastport Mastic Beach New York
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $2659 -$1041 +$837 +$503 -$113
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $5611 -$2198 +$1765 +$1060 -$240
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $5211 -$2040 +$1641 +$986 -$221

The Post DUI insurance in Shirley, NY's is $2659 compared to East Moriches (-$1041), Eastport (+$837), Mastic Beach (+$503) and New York (-$113)

In Shirley, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $400 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2006 Toyota Camry Standard in Shirley, NY would pay $5046 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $4687.

Shirley Car Insurance by Segment

Shirley Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

1940 Shirley Teenagers (7% of total population), 47% Male & 53% Female.

Shirley Ridge Mastic Beach Remsenburg-Speonk New York
All Teenagers $2917 +$183 +$551 +$775 -$125
Male Teenager $3017 +$190 +$570 +$802 -$129
Female Teenager $2802 +$177 +$530 +$745 -$119

Shirley teenagers pay $2917 in insurance in contrast with Ridge (+$183), Mastic Beach (+$551), Remsenburg-Speonk (+$775) and New York (-$125). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Shirley is $215

Example

  • 2012 Buick LaCrosse Premium 1 Male Teenager Insurance Rate $2,747
  • 2011 Lincoln MKS Base Female Teenager Insurance Rate $2,879

Shirley Men & Women Car Insurance

25136 Shirley Adults (100% of total population), 50% Men & 50% Women.

Shirley Mastic Beach Middle Island Mastic New York
All Women $1329 +$252 -$27 +$19 -$56
Married Women $1287 +$243 -$27 +$18 -$55
All Men $1987 +$376 -$41 +$28 -$85
Married Men $1916 +$362 -$40 +$27 -$82

The typical insurance rate of $1987 that Shirley Men pay varies from Mastic Beach (+$376), Middle Island (-$41), Mastic (+$28) and New York (-$85). In Shirley, married men pay $629 more than married women.

Example

  • 2014 Hyundai Tucson Limited Married Men Insurance Rate $1,813
  • 2013 Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD CC Work Truck Married Women Insurance Rate $1,851

Shirley Senior Car Insurance

3314 Shirley Seniors (13% of total population), 51% Senior Men & 49% Senior Women.

Shirley Ridge East Patchogue Center Moriches New York
All Seniors $1615 +$102 -$327 -$632 -$69
Senior Men $1716 +$108 -$348 -$672 -$74
Senior Women $1487 +$93 -$302 -$583 -$64

Shirley seniors pay $1615 in insurance compared to Ridge (+$102), East Patchogue (-$327), Center Moriches (-$632) and New York (-$69). In Shirley, senior men pay $229 more than senior women.

Shirley Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Shirley Population with 1 Vehicle 1269 (17% of Shirley population), 2 Vehicles 3827 (51% of the Shirley population) and 3 vehicles 1568 (21% of the population)

Shirley Yaphank Ridge Mastic New York
2 Vehicles $2717 -$399 +$171 +$38 -$115
3 Vehicles $4147 -$609 +$261 +$58 -$176
4 Vehicles $5577 -$819 +$351 +$78 -$237

Shirley Insurance Rates by Make

Shirley Acura Insurance

Shirley rates for Acura MDX is $1288 compared to Acura RDX (-$0) Acura ZDX (-$280) & Acura TL (-$300).

Shirley rates for Acura TSX models such as Sport Wagon, TSX, Sport Wagon Tech & Tech are nearly $1401 to $1589. The rates for a car such as 2009 Acura TSX Sport Wagon 4 Door Wagon would be about $1380 which is about 6% of the total cost of a car.

Shirley Audi Insurance

Shirley rates for Audi TTS 2.0 Quattro is $1777 compared to Audi TT (+$90) Audi Q5 (+$300) & Audi Q7 (+$10).

ModelsInsurance RateRidgeMiller PlaceVillage of the BranchSetauket-East Setauket
S5$1870-$210-$630-$630-$670
S4$1800-$200-$610-$610-$650
A3$1470-$160-$500-$500-$530
A5$1600-$180-$540-$540-$570
A4$1550-$170-$520-$520-$560
A7$1780-$200-$600-$600-$640
A6$1780-$200-$600-$600-$640
A8$2140-$240-$720-$720-$770

Shirley BMW Insurance

BMW X series models such as XDrive 35i, 35D, 35I, XDrive 50i, 5.0i, xDrive 35i & xDrive 28i cost about $1655 to $1326 in Shirley compared to BMW 7 series (-$650) BMW 3 series (-$140) & BMW 5 series (-$120).

Shirley rates for BMW Z series models such as 28i sDRIVE, 35is sDRIVE & 35i sDRIVE are approximately $1513 to $1852. A 2011 BMW Z4 35i sDRIVE 2 Door Convertible's insurance costs in Shirley is $1820 and differs from places such as Quiogue (-$690), Selden (-$210), Southampton (+$210), East Quogue (+$560) and West Islip (+$600).

ModelsInsurance RateWest BabylonNorth PatchogueStony BrookLaurel
6 series$3090+$630+$310-$1020-$1200
1 series$1520+$310+$150-$500-$590
M series$2200+$450+$220-$720-$850

Shirley Buick Insurance

Buick Enclave insurance rate is $1285 in Shirley. Insurance for a 2009 Buick Enclave 4 Door 2WD Utility in Shirley is $1260 compared to nearby locations such as Deer Park (-$310), Holtsville (-$270), Shoreham (+$410), Aquebogue (+$410) and Brightwaters (+$420).

Buick Regal insurance rate is $1293 in Shirley. The rates for a car such as 2008 Buick Regal 4 Door Sedan would be about $1270 which is about 10% of the total cost of a car.

Shirley rates for Buick Lacrosse models such as Premium II, Leather, Premium I, Touring & Lacrosse are about $1285 to $1337. Insurance for a 2011 Buick Lacrosse Premium II 4 Door Sedan in Shirley is $1270 while nearby places such as East Northport and Poquott are costlier by $390 and $410 respectively whereas Farmingville, Medford and North Bellport are cheaper by $220, $80 and $50 respectively.

Shirley Cadillac Insurance

Cadillac CTS models such as Luxury, Premium, CTS, Performance & V cost about $1472 to $1785 in Shirley. The rates for a car such as 2013 Cadillac CTS Performance 2 Door Coupe would be about $1550 which is about 3% of the total cost of a car.

Shirley rates for Cadillac SRX models such as SRX, Performance Turbo AWD, Luxury, Performance, Premium & Premium Turbo AWD are nearly $1332 to $1485. Insurance for a 2012 Cadillac SRX Premium Turbo AWD 4 Door Utility in Shirley is $1470 while nearby places such as Ridge, Port Jefferson and Setauket-East Setauket are costlier by $160, $420 and $530 respectively whereas Center Moriches and North Bellport are cheaper by $540 and $60 respectively.

Cadillac Escalade models such as Escalade, Luxury, ESV, Premium, EXT, ESV Luxury, EXT Luxury, EXT Premium, ESV Premium, Platinum, Hybrid, ESV Platinum & Platinum Hybrid cost around $1639 to $1946 in Shirley. Insurance for a 2011 Cadillac Escalade Luxury 4 Door Utility Ethanol in Shirley is $1640 is different from close by regions such as Islip Terrace (-$450), Brookhaven (-$310), Bay Shore (-$210), Islandia (-$180) and Dix Hills (+$640).

Shirley Chevrolet Insurance

Shirley rates for Chevrolet Silverado models such as 1500 LT, 1500 LTZ & 1500 Work Truck are roughly $1303 to $1266 compared to Chevrolet Express (+$50) Chevrolet Camaro (-$140) & Chevrolet Corvette (-$410).

Shirley rates for Chevrolet Equinox models such as LS, 1LT, LS AWD, 2LT, LT AWD, LTZ, 2LT AWD & LTZ AWD are around $1190 to $1306. Insurance for a 2013 Chevrolet Equinox LTZ 2WD 4 Door Utility in Shirley is $1240 is different from close by regions such as Suffolk County (-$420), Selden (-$140), Manorville (+$400), East Shoreham (+$420) and Setauket-East Setauket (+$440).

ModelsInsurance RatePoospatuckNorth SeaRemsenburg-SpeonkDix Hills
Cruze$1340-$360-$430-$430-$520
Malibu$1340-$360-$430-$430-$520
Avalanche$1400-$380-$450-$450-$540

Shirley Chrysler Insurance

Chrysler 300 models such as 300 & S cost nearly $1302 to $1440 in Shirley. Insurance for a 2010 Chrysler 300 4 Door Sedan in Shirley is $1280 while nearby places such as Mastic, Nesconset and Sayville are costlier by $80, $380 and $480 respectively whereas Fire Island and Port Jefferson Station are cheaper by $340 and $260 respectively.

Chrysler 300C insurance rate is $1404 in Shirley. A 2010 Chrysler 300C 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Shirley is $1380 is different from nearby locations such as Shoreham (+$440), Remsenburg-Speonk (+$440), Wading River (+$480), Setauket-East Setauket (+$490) and Moriches (+$520).

Shirley rates for Chrysler Town models such as & Country Touring, & Country Touring L & & Country Limited are roughly $1178 to $1245. A 2012 Chrysler Town & Country Touring L 4 Door Wagon's insurance costs in Shirley is $1180 while nearby places such as Nesconset and Sayville are costlier by $350 and $440 respectively whereas East Moriches, Islip Terrace and North Bay Shore are cheaper by $430, $330 and $80 respectively.

Chrysler 200 models such as LX, Touring & Limited cost nearly $1294 to $1348 in Shirley. The rates for a car such as 2012 Chrysler 200 Limited 4 Door Sedan would be about $1330 which is about 7% of the total cost of a car.

Shirley Dodge Insurance

Shirley rates for Dodge Grand Caravan SXT is $1186 compared to Dodge Avenger (-$180) Dodge Durango (-$180) & Dodge Challenger (-$260).

Dodge Charger models such as SXT, SE, R/T & SRT8 cost nearly $1445 to $1829 in Shirley. The rates for a car such as 2012 Dodge Charger SXT 4 Door Sedan would be about $1430 which is about 7% of the total cost of a car.

Dodge Journey models such as SXT & Crew cost roughly $1229 to $1253 in Shirley. A 2008 Dodge Journey Crew 4 Door 2WD Wagon's insurance costs in Shirley is $1230 while nearby places such as Mastic Beach, Quogue, Poquott, St. James and Jamesport are costlier by $300, $370, $400, $400 and $440 respectively

Shirley Ford Insurance

Shirley rates for Ford Taurus models such as Limited, SHO AWD, SEL AWD, Limited AWD, SEL & SE are approximately $1376 to $1287 compared to Ford Transit (+$160) Ford Mustang (-$140) & Ford Explorer (+$60).

Ford Focus models such as SE, S & Titanium cost about $1293 to $1404 in Shirley. A 2009 Ford Focus SE 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Shirley is $1270 in contrast with places such as North Great River (-$390), Riverhead (-$330), North Bellport (-$50), Westhampton Beach (+$450) and Fort Salonga (+$470).

ModelsInsurance RateEast MorichesMedfordNesconsetPeconic
Flex$1360+$500+$90-$410-$480
F-150$1280+$470+$80-$380-$450
Expedition$1400+$510+$90-$420-$490
Fiesta$1270+$460+$80-$380-$450
Fusion$1330+$480+$90-$400-$470
Edge$1300+$470+$80-$390-$460

Shirley GMC Insurance

GMC Acadia models such as SLT, Denali & SLE cost around $1196 to $1278 in Shirley compared to GMC Sierra (-$130) GMC Yukon (-$70) & GMC Terrain (+$60).

Shirley Honda Insurance

Shirley rates for Honda Fit models such as Sport & Fit are nearly $1276 to $1260 compared to Honda Insight (-$100) Honda CR-Z (-$130) & Honda Accord (-$60).

Shirley rates for Honda Civic models such as LX & EX are about $1325 to $1354. A 2010 Honda Civic EX 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Shirley is $1330 while nearby places such as Ocean Beach is costlier by $470 whereas East Islip, Islip, East Patchogue and North Patchogue are cheaper by $520, $340, $220 and $140 respectively.

ModelsInsurance RateRidgeLake GroveBlue PointShinnecock Hills
CR-V$1220-$130-$390-$390-$470
Odyssey$1220-$130-$390-$390-$470
Pilot$1310-$140-$410-$420-$510

Shirley Hyundai Insurance

Hyundai Genesis models such as 2.0T Premium, 2.0T Track, 3.8 Track, 2.0T, R-Spec, Genesis & 3.8 Grand Touring cost approximately $1446 to $1525 in Shirley compared to Hyundai Veloster (+$200) Hyundai Elantra (+$140) & Hyundai Sonata (+$170).

Shirley rates for Hyundai Accent models such as GS, SE & GLS are approximately $1341 to $1372. The rates for a car such as 2010 Hyundai Accent GLS 4 Door Sedan would be about $1350 which is about 9% of the total cost of a car.

Hyundai Equus insurance rate is $1765 in Shirley. Insurance for a 2008 Hyundai Equus 4 Door Sedan in Shirley is $1740 is different from nearby locations such as Selden (-$200), Brentwood (-$70), Village of the Branch (+$590), Mount Sinai (+$650) and Head of the Harbor (+$660).

Hyundai Tucson models such as GL, GLS & Limited cost nearly $1162 to $1252 in Shirley. Insurance for a 2012 Hyundai Tucson Limited 4WD 4 Door Utility in Shirley is $1230 while nearby places such as Nissequogue and West Hampton Dunes are costlier by $410 and $460 respectively whereas Quiogue, East Moriches and Port Jefferson Station are cheaper by $470, $450 and $250 respectively.

Shirley Jeep Insurance

Shirley rates for Jeep Patriot models such as Sport & Limited are roughly $1131 to $1221. The rates for a car such as 2013 Jeep Patriot Sport 2WD 4 Door Utility would be about $1120 which is about 7% of the total cost of a car.

Shirley rates for Jeep Grand models such as Cherokee Limited, Cherokee Laredo & Cherokee Overland are about $1272 to $1294. Insurance for a 2011 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2WD 4 Door Utility in Shirley is $1260 and is in contrast with close by places such as East Islip (-$500), Centereach (-$260), Farmingville (-$220), Baywood (-$170) and West Bay Shore (+$440).

Jeep Compass models such as Sport & Limited cost approximately $1205 to $1240 in Shirley. Insurance for a 2013 Jeep Compass Limited 4WD 4 Door Utility in Shirley is $1220 while nearby places such as Old Field, Smithtown, Greenlawn and Sayville are costlier by $390, $400, $400 and $460 respectively whereas Brookhaven is cheaper by $230.

Shirley Kia Insurance

Shirley rates for Kia Optima models such as EX, SX & LX are nearly $1408 to $1341 compared to Kia Soul (+$110) Kia Rio (+$20) & Kia Forte (+$40).

ModelsInsurance RateRiverheadBaywoodCommackWest Bay Shore
Sportage$1270+$330+$180-$430-$450
Sorento$1280+$340+$180-$430-$450
Sedona$1260+$330+$170-$420-$440

Shirley Lexus Insurance

Shirley rates for Lexus ES 350 is $1455 compared to Lexus IS (-$150) Lexus GX460 (-$60) & Lexus GX (-$60).

Shirley rates for Lexus LS models such as 460 & 460 L are approximately $1903 to $2018. Insurance for a 2012 Lexus LS 460 L 4 Door Sedan AWD in Shirley is $1990 and differs from close by places such as West Sayville (-$770), Holtsville (-$420), Ridge (+$220), Aquebogue (+$640) and Babylon (+$830).

Lexus RX models such as 350 & 450h cost approximately $1440 to $1498 in Shirley. The rates for a car such as 2009 Lexus RX 350 4 Door Utility would be about $1420 which is about 10% of the total cost of a car.

Shirley Lincoln Insurance

Shirley rates for Lincoln MKZ models such as MKZ & Hybrid are roughly $1438 to $1482 compared to Lincoln MKT (-$0) Lincoln Navigator (-$150) & Lincoln MKS (-$160).

Lincoln MKX insurance rate is $1360 in Shirley. A 2013 Lincoln MKX 4 Door 4WD SUV's insurance costs in Shirley is $1340 while nearby places such as Stony Brook, Great River, New Suffolk, Dix Hills and Laurel are costlier by $440, $470, $500, $520 and $520 respectively

Shirley Mazda Insurance

Shirley rates for Mazda Mazda6s models such as Touring Plus & Mazda6s are roughly $1374 to $1432 compared to Mazda Mazda5 (+$110) Mazda MX5 (+$170) & Mazda Mazda2 (+$150).

ModelsInsurance RateBrookhavenBrentwoodHampton BaysNorthport
CX-9$1280+$240+$60-$500-$500
Mazda3i$1390+$260+$60-$540-$540
Mazda3s$1430+$270+$60-$550-$560
Mazdaspeed3$1470+$280+$60-$570-$580
Mazda6i$1320+$250+$60-$510-$520

Shirley Nissan Insurance

Shirley rates for Nissan Murano models such as SL, SV, LE, CrossCabriolet & S are around $1277 to $1263 compared to Nissan Armada (-$210) Nissan Sentra (-$180) & Nissan Maxima (-$260).

ModelsInsurance RateBohemiaCutchogueCenterportFort Salonga
Pathfinder$1250+$480-$420-$470-$470
NV3500$1350+$520-$450-$500-$500
Altima$1520+$590-$510-$570-$570
Rogue$1310+$510-$440-$490-$490
Titan$1370+$530-$460-$510-$510
370Z$1530+$590-$520-$570-$570
Quest$1340+$520-$450-$500-$500
Versa$1300+$500-$440-$490-$490
Juke$1330+$510-$450-$500-$500

Shirley Toyota Insurance

Toyota 4Runner models such as SR5 & Limited cost nearly $1288 to $1310 in Shirley compared to Toyota Sequoia (-$20) Toyota Camry (-$30) & Toyota Corolla (-$20).

Toyota Avalon Limited insurance rate is $1319 in Shirley. A 2009 Toyota Avalon Limited 4 Door Sedan's insurance costs in Shirley is $1300 is different from places such as West Sayville (-$500), Baywood (-$180), Rocky Point (-$90), Wyandanch (+$110) and New Suffolk (+$490).

Toyota Prius models such as c, v, Prius & Plug-In hybrid cost nearly $1268 to $1347 in Shirley. Insurance for a 2013 Toyota Prius v 4 Door Wagon Hybrid in Shirley is $1260 while nearby places such as Greenlawn, Elwood, West Bay Shore and Mattituck are costlier by $420, $420, $440 and $450 respectively whereas North Patchogue is cheaper by $130.

Toyota Sienna insurance rate is $1174 in Shirley. The rates for a car such as 2011 Toyota Sienna 5 Door Wagon would be about $1160 which is about 10% of the total cost of a car.

Shirley Volkswagen Insurance

Shirley rates for Volkswagen Eos 2.0T is $1483 compared to Volkswagen Touareg (-$90) Volkswagen Tiguan (+$70) & Volkswagen Passat (+$150).

Shirley rates for Volkswagen Jetta models such as S, SE, S Sport, SEL & TDI are about $1223 to $1437. Insurance for a 2008 Volkswagen Jetta SEL 4 Door Sedan in Shirley is $1380 while nearby places such as Calverton, Remsenburg-Speonk and Northport are costlier by $220, $440 and $540 respectively whereas Medford and North Bellport are cheaper by $90 and $60 respectively.

ModelsInsurance RateFire IslandFarmingvilleSound BeachSouthampton
Golf$1340+$350+$230+$130-$160
CC$1410+$370+$250+$130-$160
GTI$1350+$350+$240+$130-$160


We also offer auto insurance in these cities NY:

  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shinhopple (Delaware County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shokan (Ulster County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shoreham (Suffolk County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shortsville (Ontario County), NY
  • Cheap Car Insurance in Shrub Oak (Westchester County), NY